Long Island Man Wanted In Connection With Two Separate 2020 Murders

If you have any information on where Colin Jerrick could be, please call or text the IN PURSUIT hotline directly: 833-378-7783 (3-PURSUE). You can also submit your tips to: InPursuitTips.com.

Colin Jerrick is a black male. Jerrick stands 5 feet 6 inches tall and weighs around 200 pounds. He may have grown out his beard.

Colin Jerrick is wanted for two different Long Island murders in 2020. If you have any information on where Colin Jerrick could be, please call or text the IN PURSUIT hotline directly: 833-378-7783 (3-PURSUE).

Photo by: FBI


By: Michelle Sigona

Wyandanch Family Day is an annual event held in Suffolk County, New York. For more than five decades, it’s been a time to bring the community together with a large parade, vendors, and celebrations. The gatherings from this annual event sometimes disperse to private homes later into the evening.

On June 12, 2020, on the day of the festival, a large party with more than 100 visitors in attendance, assembled at a local home on Grand Boulevard. The gathering was peaceful until gunfire erupted.

Late into the night, partygoers called 911 pleading for help. According to Suffolk County Police, more than 20 calls were placed to the dispatch center. Witnesses said there were multiple shots fired, numerous people were injured, and victims needed immediate help. Suffolk County Police immediately sent two teams of detectives to the location.

While working their way through a chaotic scene, investigators said first responders were able to locate eight people who were injured and needed immediate care. One of the victims was shot and in critical condition and another male victim did not make it. The victim who died was later identified as 23-year-old cancer survivor, Ajala “A.J.” Carpenter-Toney. His family said it was one of his first events since learning he was cancer free.

After an intense and lengthy investigation, including reviewing a large amount of video from the scene and questioning witnesses, authorities were led to a suspect they identified as Colin Jerrick.

Not only is Jerrick wanted for this incident, but authorities soon learned he was allegedly involved in another deadly incident. On July 31, 2020, only weeks after Carpenter-Toney was killed, 28-year-old Elbert Wright was also murdered. The incident took place outside a home in North Amityville.

Jerrick stands 5 feet 6 inches tall and weighs around 200 pounds. He may have grown out his beard. It’s possible Jerrick could also speak with an accent.

Authorities said Jerrick has connections to Florida, mainly because he has a child with a woman who lives there. He also has close connections to New York, according to law enforcement, because of his larger family. Jerrick also has ties to Guyana.

Detectives said Jerrick was a wrestling coach for high school children and he was a “stand out” wrestler himself while in school.

Police said Jerrick could be armed and dangerous. If you have any information, please call or text the IN PURSUIT hotline: 833-378-7783 (3-PURSUE) or submit your tip to: InPursuitTips.com.

Next Up

Texas Girl, 9, Fatally Shot By Suspect Firing Into Wrong Apartment, Police Say

Aspiring rapper Tyrese Simmons is accused of fatally shooting Brandoniya Bennett.

True Crime News Roundup: Pregnant Woman Fatally Shot Two Weeks Before Her Due Date

Plus: Brian Laundrie’s father joins the search for his fugitive son; a group of investigators believe they’ve identified the Zodiac Killer; and a convicted con man on the run for decades is possibly spotted at a Dodgers game.

Fugitive Captured In Mexico After Deadly Shooting

In August 2022, U.S. Marshals tracked Jonathan Dorado to Tijuana, Mexico where he was arrested and extradited back to the United States. Dorado is behind bars at the Merced County Jail in California where he faces murder and attempted murder charges.

Did A Social Media Post Lead To The Robbery And Killing Of Rapper PnB Rock?

The Philadelphia native rapper was shot at Roscoe’s House of Chicken and Waffles in Los Angeles, California on Sept. 12, 2022.

Convicted Killer Robert Durst Faces Murder Trial In Connection To His Wife’s 1982 Disappearance

One-time Manhattan real estate heir Robert Durst was found guilty in California of the first-degree murder of his best friend and confidante, Susan Berman.

Aspiring Drug Kingpin Fatally Shot Newlyweds, Plotted Murder-For-Hire Scheme

James Charles Tooley was connected to the 2008 double homicide after his cousin turned him in.

Thayne Smika Has Been On The Run Since 1983 When He May Have Murdered His Roommate

According to investigators, Sid Wells told Thayne Smika he needed to step up and pay for his portion of the rent, and a specific date was given for Smika to hand the money over: August 1, 1983 — the same day Wells was murdered.

Man Freed After Spending 21 Years In Prison For Murder Despite Another Man’s Confession

McKinley ‘Mac’ Phipps said he had stopped believing in people and the system: ‘Everything was just dark.’

Featured Cases

More Missing