Have You Seen Missing New Jersey Teen Neilina “Nelly” Tolentino?

The last sighting of her was between July 2020 and October 2020. Police believe Nelly was spotted with an unknown adult male several times in Atlantic City, New Jersey.

June 02, 2021
Both photos shown are of Neilina Tolentino. She was last seen on May 26, 2020. [via National Center for Missing and Exploited Children]

Both photos shown are of Neilina Tolentino. She was last seen on May 26, 2020. [via National Center for Missing and Exploited Children]

Both photos shown are of Neilina Tolentino. She was last seen on May 26, 2020. [via National Center for Missing and Exploited Children]

By: Michelle Sigona

Related To:

On May 26, 2020, Neilina “Nelly” Tolentino vanished without a trace from Reading, Pennsylvania. She was only 14 years old at the time of her disappearance. One year after Nelly went missing, her mother Cathilina Padilla spoke to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children (NCMEC) about just how difficult the last year has been for her family and how desperate they are to find Nelly.

On the day her daughter went missing, Padilla said, “I woke up to her not here.” Since then, Nelly missed the holidays, her 15th birthday in March with her family, she missed spending Mother’s Day with her mom, and her siblings have been heartbroken.

Nelly’s disappearance has taken a tremendous toll on everyone who knows her. Padilla wants everyone to know the hardest part of a child going missing is, “having a part of me out there, not knowing where she's at, if she's okay.” Padilla also added another incredibly tough piece of this puzzle: “I don’t know if she’s safe. I need to know if she’s safe.”

Clues to find Nelly

It’s possible Nelly could be or have connections to Atlantic City, New Jersey and Philadelphia. The last sighting of her, according to NCMEC, was between July 2020 and October 2020. Police believe Nelly was spotted with an unknown adult male several times in Atlantic City.

Reading Police lead Criminal Investigator Steve Valdez will follow up on any tip that is sent into the hotline. Valdez believes in this case, “no detail is ever too small to follow up on.”

Nelly stands 5 feet tall and weighs 120 pounds. She has brown hair and brown eyes. She is known to sometimes wear glasses and her ears are pierced. She’s seen in previous photos wearing larger hoop earrings. NCMEC created a video about Nelly, a little more than one minute long.

Nelly’s mother said this in the video message:, “I miss everything we did together. I miss your smile, I miss your laugh.” Padilla added, “Your sister misses you, your brothers miss you, everyone misses you and wishes that you would just come home.”

Contact NCMEC with your leads on this case

Padilla wants to reach her teen daughter and she especially wants her to know:, “I love you very much, and I pray that you’re okay.”

If you know anything about this case or where Nelly could be, please contact the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children directly: 800-THE-LOST

Next Up

Have You Seen Missing Teenagers Asia Wilbon Or Mackenzie Marken?

Both girls vanished during the night from their families’ homes.

Kayla Unbehaun, Missing Since 2017, Found Safe In Asheville

Kayla Unbehaun was abducted from Illinois by her biological mother, Heather Unbehaun, on Independence Day 2017. 6 years later, she was found safe in North Carolina.

What Happened To Tonetta Carlisle? Authorities Say Teen Was Abducted From Tennessee

Tonetta Carlisle was last seen being forced into a vehicle in Chattanooga on March 16, 1989. If you know anything about Tonetta's case, please contact the Chattanooga Police directly: 423-698-2525.

New Jersey Investigators Use Artificial Intelligence To Investigate 1991 Missing Child Case

“People don't know that I cry behind closed doors,” Maureen Himebaugh says about not knowing what happened to her “adorable, intuitive, sweet” son, Mark.

Missing Alabama Woman May Have Been Kidnapped And Pushed Off A Cliff

Mary Elizabeth Isbell Wright has been missing for nearly two years. After a long investigation, Loretta Kay Carr, 43, has been arrested and charged for kidnapping and murdering her.

Police Looking At Cold Case Murders Of 2 Teens After Kidnapping Of 9-Year-Old New York Girl

Detectives believe “there is a strong possibility” the two women’s deaths could trace back to one still-unidentified suspect.

True Crime News Roundup: Texas Mom Allegedly Strangled Her 5-Year-Old Daughter While She Pleaded For Her Life

Plus: Paul Flores found guilty of murdering Kristin Smart; Princeton student found dead; Man confesses to spring break murder of Brittanee Drexel; Mississippi daycare workers arrested for child abuse.

The Alissa Turney Case: What If You Thought Your Dad Killed Your Stepsister?

Over the years, police have declined to arrest Michael Turney or to name him a suspect, but daughter Sarah is convinced that Michael may know more than he has revealed.

Amber Alert Activated More Than A Year After Tennessee Teen Vanishes

Daphne Westbrook was allegedly kidnapped in 2019 and found safe in May 2021.

DNA Ties Two Virginia College Students’ Homicides To ‘Back-To-School Killer’

One victim’s mother called Jesse Matthew Jr. "a serial rapist and murderer who had been hiding in plain sight."

Featured Cases

More Missing