Police Said Teen Holly Moore Committed Suicide, But Not Everyone Is Convinced

Troubling questions about Holly Moore's hanging death just one week after she turned 19 have many calling for a new investigation.

June 26, 2019
Holly Moore [Investigation Discovery]
By: Mike McPadden

CASTLE ROCK, CO — On March 6, 2015, just one week after she turned 19, the body of college student Holly Moore was discovered hanging in her bathroom closet with an electrical cord wrapped around her neck.

Holly’s roommate reportedly found her, dialed 911, and then called Ray Moore, Holly’s father. After Ray raced to the scene, he said, Castle Rock Police officers told him on the spot that his daughter had committed suicide.

Indeed, the police recorded Holly’s death as a suicide in their original report. So, too, did Dr. James A. Wilkerson IV the Douglas County Coroner’s Office after he performed an autopsy.

Ray Moore, however, didn’t believe Holly killed herself then, and he doesn’t believe it now.

The still grieving dad has been up front about the challenges his daughter faced at the time — she was a full-time caregiver for her quadriplegic mother and she had been prescribed antidepressants which, Ray admits, Holly had run out of in the days before she died.

In addition, Holly had recently split from her boyfriend, an Army specialist referred to solely as "Steven." The night she died, text messages sent from Holly’s phone reportedly indicated that the exes were fighting.

Steven is said to have accused Holly of being involved with her male roommate. Police say a reply message from Holly’s phone declared, “You don’t deserve a goodbye,” and included a photo of her thigh with the names of friends and family members written on it — with “Steven” in the middle. The text conversation allegedly ended there.

During the initial police investigation, April Moore, Holly’s sister, says she told officers that she suspected Steven might be involved in the death. April alleged that just a week prior, on Holly’s 19th birthday, she witnessed Steven choking her sister.

April told a reporter, “I saw him lifting her up with just one hand, and Holly was off the ground almost a foot. Holly was turning red, she couldn’t breathe. She was saying, 'stop, stop, stop!'”

The station additionally reported that a second witness went on record with the cops claiming Steven “put [Holly] in a choke hold to get her to pass out.”

CBI Agent In Charge Kirby Lewis, however, after speaking with with multiple officials, was not able to find any backup supporting the claims of abuse.

Ray and April also reported that Holly’s room was tidy to the point of being spotless, looking, to them, like someone had cleaned it extremely thoroughly, perhaps, they theorized, to eliminate or cover up evidence.

Regardless, Castle Rock Sargent Tim Ratcliff told the press that authorities were standing by their original determination, stating, “The totality of the situation led us to believe that this was a suicide.”

Determined to keep looking into Holly’s death, her family hired renowned forensic medical examiner Dr. Selma Eikelenboom.

Reportedly, Eikelenboom requested X-rays of Holly’s remains from the County Coroner, but the office refused to provide them. Eikelboom said she X-rayed the body at the funeral home instead and noted that Holly had a broken collarbone.

The coroner’s office reportedly later said the break occurred during the autopsy, but Eikelenboom pointed out that no record of any such break was included in the report.

Eikelenboom reportedly went on to state that Holly had injuries on her lip and chin, indicating she might have been kicked. The doctor also noted that the deep horizontal ligature marks on Holly’s neck were inconsistent with the vertical marks left by a typical hanging suicide. She said, in fact, they seemed to be more in keeping with marks left by strangulation.

Furthermore, Eikelenboom said the fact that Holly’s fingers were tightly wrapped underneath the electrical cord around her neck only made sense if “she was strangled by somebody else and she is trying to fight if off.”

Talking to KDVR-TV, Eikelenboom said, “The more we investigate, the more indications we get that this is indeed a homicide and not a suicide.”

Allegedly motivated by public pressure for Holly’s death to be reconsidered, on December 24, 2015, the Castle Rock Police Department (CRPD) reportedly handed the case over to the Colorado Bureau of Investigation (CBI) for a peer review.

On February 1, 2017, CBI Agent In Charge Kirby Lewis reportedly completed the multifaceted review and the agency backed up the cops’ original finding — that Holly Moore died by her own hand.

The review further stated that the CBI looked deep into the police work, the county medical exam records, and all the information provided by the independent investigators hired by Holly’s family, and concluded that the case had been handled properly.

Nonetheless, Ray Moore remains convinced that someone killed his daughter. He and others have pledged to continue seeking justice for Holly — and to continue asking questions.

For more on the case of Holly Moore, watch Investigation Discovery's Still a Mystery on ID GO!

Next Up

Police Release New Sketch & Recordings Of Delphi Killer Who Is 'Hiding In Plain Sight'

During the press conference, Superintendent Carter pointed out that the killer could be in the room with police and reporters.

Sister Of Delphi Murder Victim Libby German Streams Live On YouTube To 'Debunk Rumors'

Kelsi German addressed speculation regarding the 2017 “Delphi Snapchat Murders” of her sister, Liberty German, and Abigail Williams.

Delphi Families Have Raised $50,000 To Build Memorial Park In Honor Of Abby & Libby

The families have said that they hope that the memorial will appeal to those who appreciate the arts and athletics, which were things that the girls both enjoyed.

Valerie Reyes Had A Premonition: Told Mom, 'I'm Afraid Someone Is Going To Murder Me'

According to her mother, it is unclear exactly who Valerie Reyes was afraid of or why she believed that she was being targeted.

2 Bodies In 2 Days: 'ID Murder Mystery' Examines The Bizarre Death Of Rebecca Zahau

Rebecca Zahau's family members have fought to have the case reexamined for years, and insisted that they believe that her death was a murder.

Did The Notorious 'In Cold Blood' Killers Murder A Second Family In Florida?

About a month earlier, Perry Smith and Dick Hickock slaughtered the four-member Clutter family in Kansas, creating the tragedy that was immortalized in author Truman Capote’s 1966 true-crime masterpiece In Cold Blood.

Realtor Murdered By Phony House Shoppers Who Fled; Who Killed Lindsay Buziak & Why?

In 2008, realtor Lindsay Buziak showed a home to an unknown pair of clients and was inexplicably stabbed to death. The search for answers continues.

'Casey Anthony: The Movie' — Is A Racy & Revealing Biopic Coming To A Theater Near You?

The notorious mom has allegedly announced a film about her hard-partying life and what she claims is a cover-up in daughter Caylee's death, noting, “There will be sex scenes.”

Did Paul Etter Commit The Delphi Snapchat Murders? Police Say They’re Investigating

Cops say Etter, who killed himself in June, may be linked to the 2017 slayings of Indiana teens Abby Williams and Libby German.