A Brief History Of The Black Dahlia Case To Prepare You For the Upcoming TV Series 'I Am The Night'

Since 1947, the brutal death of 22-year-old Elizabeth Short has remained Hollywood’s most enduring unsolved mystery.

January 25, 2019

Elizabeth Short [Getty Images/Bettmann/Contributor]

Elizabeth Short [Getty Images/Bettmann/Contributor]

By: Matt Gilligan

LOS ANGELES, CA — It has been 72 years since the young woman who became infamously known as the "Black Dahlia" was found brutalized and mutilated in a vacant lot in Los Angeles. Since January 15, 1947, the death of 22-year-old Elizabeth Short has remained Hollywood’s most enduring unsolved mystery.

The case rocked post-war Los Angeles and had all the ingredients to mesmerize the public: a vicious murder, a beautiful young woman who longed to break into the movie industry, multiple suspects, and a press corps that latched onto the story and made the grisly killing front-page news. But more than seven decades later, the question remains: who killed Elizabeth Short?

Many people believe they know who was responsible for the death of the Black Dahlia. His name was Dr. George Hodel, a brilliant and successful physician who rubbed elbows with Hollywood’s elite power players and was never charged with the crime that remains an explosive chapter in Los Angeles lore.

Elizabeth Short was a native of Massachusetts who ended up in Northern California during World War II. She originally headed west in 1942 to reconnect with her long-lost father, whom she believed had killed himself when she was only six years old.

Police bulletin distributed by the Los Angeles Police Department [WikiCommons/City of Los Angeles Police Department]

Police bulletin distributed by the Los Angeles Police Department [WikiCommons/City of Los Angeles Police Department]

Short then migrated to Southern California and worked for a time at a military base. She had a fondness for men in uniform that would last the rest of her short life.

In September 1943 at the age of 19, Short was arrested for underage drinking at a bar in Santa Barbara and was given a choice by authorities: She could stay in California and face charges, or return home to her mother in Massachusetts. She chose to return to the East Coast and eventually moved to Miami and worked as a waitress.

In April 1946, Short returned to Southern California, where she would spend the final nine months of her life drifting between boarding houses and hotel rooms with various roommates. She sometimes worked as a waitress, but longed to be a movie star like countless other young, beautiful women who descend on Hollywood.

In December 1946, Short took a trip to San Diego with a man named Robert “Red” Manley, a 25-year-old salesman she was dating. On January 9, 1947, the pair returned to Los Angeles, and Manley dropped Short off at the Biltmore Hotel in downtown Los Angeles.

Short was supposed to meet her sister there, who was visiting from Boston. Witnesses reported seeing Elizabeth Short in the lobby of the hotel. She then exited the hotel and vanished.

Nearly a week later, on the morning of January 15, 1947, a woman walking with her young daughter spotted Short’s body in a vacant lot in the Leimert Park neighborhood of Los Angeles. The woman originally believed the body was a mannequin, but upon closer inspection realized it was a nude female body that had been cut in half with the precision of a surgeon.

Upon further examination, investigators realized the body had also been completely drained of blood and washed before it was dumped in the lot. In addition to the bisection, Short’s body had been grotesquely mutilated: Her mouth had been slashed from ear to ear, known as a “Glasgow smile.” Her thighs and breasts had been cut, and Short’s body was posed with her legs spread apart and her arms raised over her head.

It appeared as if the killer regarded his victim as a work of art. An autopsy determined Elizabeth Short had been dead for 24 hours or less. The two pressing questions authorities had to answer were who committed the grisly murder, and where had Elizabeth Short been for nearly a week, alive, after leaving the Biltmore Hotel?

The press nicknamed Short “the Black Dahlia” as a twist on a popular film from the previous year entitled The Blue Dahlia, because of Short’s eye-catching black hair and often black clothing. The sensational story was front-page news with investigators and amateur sleuths alike trying to determine who was responsible for the murder.

The alleged killer sent taunting notes to Los Angeles newspapers, which were reprinted and kept the story in the headlines for months. The list of suspects was enormous. Short was known to date many men, and police tediously worked through their list of men. Red Manley, the man who dropped Short off at the Biltmore Hotel, was originally the prime suspect, but was later dismissed. Despite a huge effort by law enforcement, the murder remains unsolved to this day

One suspect’s name continues to reappear throughout the years: Dr. George Hodel. The wealthy physician ran a clinic treating venereal diseases and has been a suspect in the Black Dahlia murder since 1949, when he was arrested for allegedly raping his 14-year-old daughter.

The LAPD suspected Hodel of several murders and he was recorded on a police bug in his house in 1950 saying, “Supposin' I did kill the Black Dahlia. They couldn't prove it now. They can't talk to my secretary anymore because she's dead.... They thought there was something fishy. Anyway, now they may have figured it out.”

Steve Hodel, George’s son, is a retired LAPD detective who set out to clear his father’s name in the 1990s, but eventually became convinced that his father had indeed killed Elizabeth Short. Steve Hodel believes his father met Short at his venereal disease clinic and that the two had a relationship outside of his work as a physician.

George Hodel’s medical background also adds to the intrigue, because of the way Short’s body was cut in half so cleanly. In 2004, unreleased Los Angeles District Attorney files that point to George Hodel as the main suspect in the Black Dahlia case were discovered in a vault, adding more evidence to Steve Hodel’s argument. Some believe George Hodel’s powerful connections in entertainment, politics, and law enforcement allowed him to avoid prosecution in the Black Dahlia murder and other cases.

George Hodel fled the United States in 1950 and lived overseas for 40 years until he returned to America in 1990. He died in 1999 at the age of 91. He was never charged in the Black Dahlia case.

The six-part series I Am the Night premieres on January 28 on TNT and is based on a book by Fauna Hodel. Fauna was the product of an incestuous relationship between George Hodel and his 14-year-old daughter Tamar. Fauna was given up as a baby and raised by an African-American mother. It wasn’t until Fauna Hodel was older that she discovered her true identity and learned about the twisted legacy of her father and her family.

Next Up

True Crime News Roundup: ‘Considerable Doubt’ Remains In Emmett Till Murder Case Despite DOJ Closing File

Plus: The body of a missing Florida woman is found near her boyfriend’s home; Scott Peterson is resentenced for his wife Laci Peterson’s 2002 murder; and former Empire actor Jussie Smollett found guilty for falsely reporting a hate crime.

True Crime News Roundup: Pregnant Woman Fatally Shot Two Weeks Before Her Due Date

Plus: Brian Laundrie’s father joins the search for his fugitive son; a group of investigators believe they’ve identified the Zodiac Killer; and a convicted con man on the run for decades is possibly spotted at a Dodgers game.

Families Suspect Drugging After Model, Friend Found Dead Outside LA Hospitals

Christy Giles was dead and her friend, Hilda Marcela Cabrales-Arzola, unresponsive when masked men wearing all black left them outside separate hospitals.

True Crime News Roundup: Gabby Petito’s Body Found, Boyfriend Remains Missing

A 16-year-old boy pleads guilty to murdering NYC college student Tessa Majors; Britney Spears gets closer to ending her conservatorship; and the Elizabeth Holmes federal Theranos fraud trial continues.

Unlicensed Mother, Daughter Accused Of Murder After Botched Butt Lift

Libby Adame and Alicia Galaz allegedly recruited new clients on Instagram and charged $14,000 for three sessions, police say.

True Crime News Roundup: Father Fatally Shoots Ex-Football Player Son During Dog Bite Argument

Plus: The remains of Wisconsin mother Ashley Carlson were found in Minnesota; An arrest has been made in connection to the deadly home invasion of music legend Clarence Avant’s California home; and a Las Vegas college student died from injuries he sustained during a “school-sanctioned amateur fight.”

Was Former Death Row Inmate Julius Jones Framed For A Murder He Didn’t Commit?

Oklahoma’s governor recently commuted the prisoner’s death sentence to life in prison without parole.

Gabby Petito Investigation: New Details Emerge In Manhunt For Fugitive Brian Laundrie

“He's somewhere where he's probably being taken care of,” a former FBI agent says.

New Cold Case Unit Investigates Case Of Teenager Found Dead Years After He Vanished

“This unit is a first step in getting closure for many families across our state,” the Texas attorney general says.

True Crime News Roundup: Inquiry Into Death Of Woman Found Dead After Bumble Date Now An Active Investigation, Police Say

Plus: A Chicago teacher and her state trooper husband are found dead in a car; the search continues for the killer of a teenager whose body was dumped near a Los Angeles freeway; Cardi B wins her defamation lawsuit against a YouTube vlogger; and a California court grants Apple CEO Tim Cook a restraining order after he’s allegedly targeted by a stalker.