Police Arrest Alleged Brooklyn Handyman Serial Killer For Deaths Of Three Women

He and the elderly alleged victims all lived in the same housing development complex for seniors.

January 25, 2021

Alleged serial killer Kevin Gavin [WABC-TV]

Alleged serial killer Kevin Gavin [WABC-TV]

By: Aaron Rasmussen

New York City police have arrested an alleged serial killer handyman and accused him of murdering three elderly women living in his Brooklyn senior housing development.

According to law enforcement officials, Kevin Gavin, 66, allegedly killed Juanita Caballero in her sixth-floor apartment at the Carter G. Woodsen Houses in Brownsville. The 78-year-old victim’s son discovered her body on Jan. 15 with a cord around the neck, and Caballero’s cause of death was ruled to be asphyxia.

Gavin reportedly often helped older people living in the New York City Housing Authority-run building with their errands.

“All the tenants know him,” one neighbor, Esther Williams, told New York’s WCBS-TV, “and he was always looking for money.”

“The defendant took advantage of his relationship with these women, was allowed into their homes, and did unspeakable acts of violence against them,” Brooklyn District Attorney Eric Gonzalez claimed, according to the news station.

Gavin, police said, may also be responsible for the death of Jacolia James, 83, found beaten to death in her apartment in May 2019, as well as the November 2015 slaying of 82-year-old Myrtle McKinney, who had suffered three broken ribs and a stab wound to the neck.

“There was some additional evidence in this most recent homicide that allowed us to make the connection,” Gonzalez said, according to WCBS-TV.

NYPD Chief of Detectives Rodney Harrison confirmed Gavin had ties to all three victims and claimed the suspected serial killer allegedly may have committed the murders “over an argument over money or finances,” WABC-TV reported.

New York Police Department officials said Gavin has been charged with multiple crimes, including three counts of second-degree murder.

Investigators are now looking into whether he could have had any connection to other deaths in the building.

According to the New York Times, loved ones and some elected officials have accused the NYCHA of having poor security and the NYPD of negligence for initially failing to properly investigate the first two murders.

In the 2015 case of McKinney, the elderly women’s death was at first determined to be caused by congestive heart failure but was later changed to homicide after a funeral director found the knife wound on her neck. Family had also noted at the time that $800 had been withdrawn from her banking account and her apartment keys had gone missing.

“They dropped the ball from the beginning,” McKinney’s son, Mark Lewis, told the Times. “If a family says something isn’t right, you should at least take the initiative to look into it.”

Brooklyn D.A. Gonzalez insisted Gavin’s case would now move forward quickly.

“I understand how devastating these losses have been to the people of Brownsville, to the residents of those houses, that these women who are beloved mothers and grandmothers and neighbors, the fear that has existed in the Woodson Houses regarding what’s happening there,” he said.

Next Up

A 'Frenzy' Of Murder: The Story Of New York Serial Killer Joel Rifkin

As a teenager, Joel Rifkin became obsessed with Alfred Hitchcock's 1972 film 'Frenzy,' about a serial killer in London who rapes and strangles women to death with a necktie.

Episode 4: Twelve Months of Misery

Twelve months of misery: Alexis and Billy revisit the investigation and the discovery of 11 victims between December 2010 and December 2011.

Episode 5: Oak Beach

A former sex worker discloses disturbing details about an encounter she had with the soon-to-be-named chief of police James Burke at a sex party in Oak Beach, a secretive community just two miles from where the LISK dumped the bodies of 11 dead sex workers.

Episode 2: Fail to the Chief

Alexis LInkletter and Billy Jensen uncover a secret from the past with incriminating information about the former Chief of Police of Suffolk County James Burke.

Episode 3: A Deal With the Devil

Alexis and Billy revisit another Long Island murder case from 1979, that of John Pius, and uncover a troubling connection with two of the authorities trusted to lead the LISK investigation

Episode 1: David and Goliath

In the first episode of Unraveled: Long Island Serial Killer Alexis Linkletter’s childhood friend claims to have key evidence that could lead to solving the ten year mystery of the Long Island Serial Killer murders. Listen now.

“Happy Face Killer”: How Keith Jesperson’s Daughter Discovered His Deadly Secret

“There was just something ‘off’ about him,” Melissa Moore says of the serial killer.

Episode 5: "The Apex Predator"

The story of a boy sex trafficking kingpin.

Suspected Serial Killer Arrested For Multiple Unsolved Murder Cold Cases

DNA allegedly links former trucker Clark Perry Baldwin to women slain in Wyoming and Tennessee.

Episode 8: "The Dust Never Settles"

The Lost Boys, then and now.