'Unbelievable': 5 Things You Might Not Know About The Real Case Behind The Hit Series

Facts about the heroic survivor and the detectives who brought a serial rapist to justice.

October 14, 2019
Mug shot of Marc O'Leary [Colorado Department of Corrections]

Photo by: Mug shot of Marc O'Leary [Colorado Department of Corrections]

Mug shot of Marc O'Leary [Colorado Department of Corrections]

By: Mike McPadden

The popular Netflix miniseries "Unbelievable" dramatizes the pursuit of convicted serial rapist Marc O'Leary. It doesn’t flinch when it comes to reporting the many mistakes made by police, parents, and other authority figures along the way.

The series creators based it on the 2015 Pulitzer Prize–winning piece, "An Unbelievable Story of Rape" by T. Christian Miller and Ken Armstrong. Like the article, the show chronicles Marie, played by Kaitlyn Dever, who is an 18-year-old rape survivor whose account of the crime was reportedly used against her to the point that she recanted her allegations.

A pair of Colorado detectives, played by Toni Collette and Merrit Weaver, worked together on cases that proved not only had Marie told the truth, but she had fallen prey to a serial rapist identified by authorities as Marc O'Leary.

In 2011, a judge reportedly sentenced O'Leary to more than 327 years in prison.

Law Enforcement Reportedly Didn't Believe Marie & "Pressured" Her To Recant Her Story

In August 2008, an 18-year-old Washington state resident identified only by her middle name, Marie, called police to report someone had raped her at knifepoint in her apartment. Marie said the assailant wore a black mask, tied her up, and took photos of her.

Responding officers reportedly told Marie to recount the incident over and over again, leading to what they claimed were inconsistencies in her story. This, the lack of physical evidence, and the fact that two of Marie’s former foster parents purportedly told police they thought she was lying led to a charge of filing a false report.

"When the police began doubting Marie, they turned on her," journalist Ken Armstrong told NPR. "The focus of the investigation became her credibility. And instead of interviewing Marie as a victim, they began interrogating her as a suspect."

Authorities reportedly wore Marie down so much that she recanted her story, and faced a charge of filing a false report, for which she paid a $500 fine. Additionally, she accepted a deal wherein the charge would be dropped if she went to mental health counseling for lying and participated in supervised probation.

"Marie buckled under that pressure," Armstrong said. "It was the easiest way out for her. So she recanted. And the way she describes it, when she did recant, it came with this tremendous sense of relief. It was almost as though she had unburdened herself."

According to reports, Marie still carried the burden not only of surviving the rape, but also the knowledge that she’d told the truth. [NPR]

Marc O'Leary Allegedly Went On To Commit More Rapes

According to a timeline of the "Unbelievable" case at Refinery 29, an October 2008 rape of a 63-year-old woman in Kirkland, Colorado had similarities with the crime committed against Marie.

The following October, a masked rapist raped a 65-year-old woman in Aurora, Colorado. A similar attack occurred in Lakewood in July 2010, but because the victim escaped, police reportedly labeled it a burglary.

Rapes with a similar methodology reportedly took place in Westminster, Colorado in August 2010 and Golden, Colorado in January 2011. [Refinery 29]

Detectives Stacey Galbraith & Edna Hendershot Worked Together & Caught The Suspect

While investigating the Golden rape, Stacy Galbraith, then a detective with the Golden Police Department, reportedly emailed the Westminster Police Department to ask if they had any open sex crimes with elements such as a pink digital camera and masked assailant who had an egg-sized birthmark on his leg. Detective Edna Hendershot of Westminster reportedly replied in the affirmative.

Gailbraith later met with Hendershot and Detective Scott Burgess of the Aurora Police Department. Together, they reportedly connected the four Colorado rapes as possibly being the work of a single perpetrator.

Evidence of a white Mazda pickup truck at one of the crime scenes reportedly as well as DNA evidence implicating a male in his family led to the identification of Marc O'Leary as a suspect. While patting down O'Leary, Galbraith reportedly saw the birthmark on his leg. [Time]

A Search Of O'Leary's Computer Found Evidence That Proved Marie Told The Truth

Following O'Leary's arrest for burglary and sexual assault on February 13, 2011, investigators allegedly gathered numerous items of evidence from his home.

A police computer expert also reportedly searched O'Leary's hard drive and discovered photographs of his victims. Among them were shots of a bound-and-gagged young woman, and, in one photo, her learner's permit was visible. It reportedly identified the victim in the photo as Marie.

Authorities in Washington state reportedly contacted Marie and the lead detective on her case ended up apologizing to her. [Harper's Bazaar]

Marc O'Leary Received More Than 327 Years in Prison For His Crimes

In October 2011, Marc O'Leary reportedly pled guilty to 28 counts of rape and associated felonies in Colorado.

At his December 2011 sentencing, O'Leary reportedly told the court, "I'm standing here because I need to be in prison. I know that probably more than anyone in this room. I've known it for a while."

Judge Philip J. McNulty reportedly responded by sentencing O'Leary to 327½ years in prison. [Denver Post]

Next Up

Bobby Joe Long, 'The Classified Ad Rapist,' Caused Tampa's Murder Rate To Skyrocket

Bobby Joe Long, who some reports claim is a distant cousin of Henry Lee Lucas, had a troubled childhood prior to his life as a violent offender.

Video: Serial Killer Ted Bundy In His Own Words

Hearing Ted Bundy's own voice describe his deranged serial killings is chilling.

The Internet's First Serial Killer: John Edward Robinson, The 'Internet Slavemaster'

John Edward Robinson was sentenced to death for his reign of terror in Kansas City in the mid-'80s.

5 Recent Developments Involving Serial Killer Clown John Wayne Gacy

The case of the monster who murdered dozens of boys and young men continues to evolve today.

Woman Who Escaped Serial Killer Uses TikTok To Empower Others Dealing With Trauma

‘I went on to survive and thrive,’ Kara Robinson Chamberlain says of life after Richard Marc Edward Evonitz kidnapped her when she was 15.

Serial Killer William Reece Pleads Guilty To The 1997 Murders Of Three Young Texas Women

Convicted murderer William Reece was sentenced to death for another young woman’s murder in August 2021.

‘Torso Killer’ Richard Cottingham Indicted In 1968 Slaying Of Long Island Dance Teacher

More than five decades after the body of 23-year-old Diane Cusick was found murdered in her car, investigators have linked her death to a serial killer.

These Five Brave Women Survived Serial Killers

These brave women beat the odds against murderers Bobby Joe Long, Ted Bundy, Richard Ramirez and Richard Speck.

Polygamist Cult Leader Who Has More Than 20 Wives Allegedly Married His Own Daughter

Samuel Rappylee Bateman, who was arrested in September 2022 on federal charges, is accused of child abuse and child sex trafficking.

Accused Rapist & Murderer Fathers Children With Woman & Her Daughter; Now On The Run

Tomas Magallon Gonzalez is described as a master manipulator of people, especially children. He’s accused of sexually assaulting his girlfriend's nine-year-old daughter for years and eventually fathering two children with her before killing her.