Who Lured Trusting 10-Year-Old Amy Mihaljevic To Her Death In 1989?

The baffling murder mystery continues to haunt friends, family and police to this day.

Amy Mihaljevic, pictured here, went missing on October 27, 1989 after being lured to the mall by a man. She was later found murdered.

Amy Mihaljevic went missing on October 27, 1989 after being lured to the mall by a strange man. She was later found murdered. Her case remains unsolved.

Photo by: Warner Bros. Discovery, Inc. (Screenshot from ID's "The Lake Erie Murders")

Warner Bros. Discovery, Inc. (Screenshot from ID's "The Lake Erie Murders")

By: Aaron Rasmussen

On October 27, 1989, Amy Mihaljevic headed to a local shopping center in Bay Village, Ohio after classes, like she had done so often in the past. Only this time, unbeknownst to her parents, the 10-year-old schoolgirl was secretly meeting a mystery man who had lured her there by asking for help buying a gift to celebrate her mom’s recent promotion at work.

Two young eyewitnesses recalled spotting the manipulative predator arrive and greet the child in front of the Baskin-Robbins ice cream shop. Mihaljevic then seemed to vanish into thin air.

As her frantic family and the police scrambled to find Mihaljevic, the terrible truth about how she was tricked into trusting someone she didn’t know began to emerge.

According to police, a mystery man had been calling local girls at home and asking them for help choosing gifts. Sadly, Mihaljevic took the bait — despite a police officer visiting her class earlier the very same day she was kidnapped and warning about stranger danger.

Her body was discovered in a remote field just over three months after she went missing.

If you have any information on the still-unsolved case, contact the Bay Village Police at 440-871-1234 or email jelish@cityofbayvillage.com.

For more on this case, stream the three-part special The Lake Erie Murders: Who Killed Amy Mihaljevic? on Max.

The 1993 Unsolved Murder Of Holly Piirainen

On Aug. 5, 1993, Holly Piirainen, 10, and her brother went to a neighbor's house to play with puppies. Her brother returned home but she never did.

Next Up

The 1993 Unsolved Murder Of Holly Piirainen

On Aug. 5, 1993, Holly Piirainen, 10, and her brother went to a neighbor's house to play with puppies. Her brother returned home but she never did.

Man Arrested After Ring Camera Captures Attempted Abduction Of 6-Year-Old Girl

33-year-old Deric McPherson was arrested on Aug. 23, 2022 after grabbing a 6-year-old girl and attempting to pull her down the sidewalk with him.

True Crime News Roundup: Elderly Man Missing For Months Found Dead In Trash Can Outside His Home

Plus: NYC sixth-grader struck and killed by stray bullet; New Hampshire police search for person of interest in double homicide; Fyre Festival fraudster released early from prison; and manhunt continues for escaped Texas prisoner.

Suspect Is Finally Charged In The Cold Case Stabbing Murder of 11-Year-Old Girl

Sixth grader Melissa Tremblay was found stabbed to death in a railway yard in 1988. Now, over 30 years later, an arrest has been made for her murder.

FedEx Driver Charged With Murder After 7-Year-Old Went Missing From Outside Her Texas Home

On Nov. 30, 2022, Athena Strand went missing from her front yard. Two days later, her body was found and 31-year-old Tanner Lynn Horner was charged with her murder.

Colorado Man Allegedly Kills Teen Coworker In Break Room After She Rejected His Advances

Riley Whitelaw, 17, had previously expressed concerns about her 28-year-old coworker Joshua Johnson, whom she said made her feel uncomfortable.

Florida Teen Sentenced To Life For Murder Of 13-Year-Old Classmate Stabbed 114 Times

Aiden Fucci allegedly told people “he was going to kill someone by taking them in the woods and stabbing them,” authorities said.

Quebec Prisoner With 89 Convictions Charged In Young Girl’s 1994 Murder

Nearly 30 years after the body of 10-year-old Marie-Chantale Desjardins was found behind a shopping center, 61-year-old Réal Courtemanche has been charged with her murder.

Texas Killing Fields: Who Murdered Dozens Of Young Girls And Women Near Houston?

The remains of at least 30 victims have been found in a remote area since the early ‘70s.

New Document Reveals Bodies Of Teenage Girls Were Staged in Delphi Killings

A recently-released FBI search warrant reveals new details about the 2017 killing of Abigail Williams and Liberty German along a public trail in Delphi, Indiana.