Who Are The Controversial Central Park Five?

The Central Park Five subsequently sued the city of New York, and ended up winning $41 million in a settlement in 2014.

May 29, 2019
1145322129

1145322129

NEW YORK, NY - MAY 20:(L-R) Kevin Richardson, Antron Mccray, Raymond Santana Jr., Korey Wise, and Yusef Salaam, collectively known as the "Central Park Five," attend the world premiere of Netflix's "When They See Us" at the Apollo Theater on May 20, 2019 in New York City [Taylor Hill/FilmMagic]

Photo by: Kevin Richardson, Antron Mccray, Raymond Santana Jr., Korey Wise, and Yusef Salaam, collectively known as the "Central Park Five." at the premiere of Netflix's "When They See Us" at New York City's Apollo Theater on May 20, 2019 [Taylor Hill/FilmMagic]

Kevin Richardson, Antron Mccray, Raymond Santana Jr., Korey Wise, and Yusef Salaam, collectively known as the "Central Park Five." at the premiere of Netflix's "When They See Us" at New York City's Apollo Theater on May 20, 2019 [Taylor Hill/FilmMagic]

By: Catherine Townsend

NEW YORK CITY — On the night of April 19, 1989, a 28-year-old white woman, later identified as Trisha Meili, was jogging in Central Park when she was attacked, and then brutally raped, sodomized, beaten, and stabbed five times.

Meili, who at the time of the attack was a vice president of the Wall Street investment bank Salomon Brothers, "lost 80 percent of her blood during an attack and rape so brutal that doctors did not expect her to live more than a few hours," according to the Florida Times-Union.

Her injuries left her in a coma for 12 days. One eye had come out of its socket, and Meili suffered massive brain damage. But despite being in such bad shape that she was even given Last Rites, Meili survived.

Photo by: Trisha Meili's bloody shirt from the attack [New York City Law Department]

Trisha Meili's bloody shirt from the attack [New York City Law Department]

Five juvenile males, whom the media would soon name the "Central Park Five," were arrested for attacking and raping Meili. The five suspects were Korey Wise, 16; Antron McCray, 15; Kevin Richardson and Raymond Santana, both 14; and 15-year-old Yusef Salaam. Four were black, and one was of Hispanic descent.

They were tried for assault, robbery, riot, rape, sexual abuse, and attempted murder. After being convicted of most charges by juries in two separate trials in 1990, the five received sentences ranging from 5 to 15 years, and spent between 6 and 13 years in prison.

But in 2002, a man named Matthias Reyes, who had been convicted of a string of crimes including brutal rapes, for which he was nicknamed "The East Side Rapist," came forward and claimed that he had been the only actual attacker. At the time of the attack, Reyes had been living in his van and working at an East Harlem bodega on Third Avenue and 102nd Street.

Reyes reportedly was moved to confess because he "found religion," but many observers believed that his true motive was a transfer and better conditions in prison. But traces of Reyes' semen were reportedly found on Meili's sock from the night of the attack, and this resulted in the charges being dropped against the Central Park Five due to a lack of DNA evidence connecting them to the crime. The five defendants' convictions were vacated by the New York Supreme Court on December 19, 2002.

Photo by: Mug shot of Matias Reyes [New York Police Department]

Mug shot of Matias Reyes [New York Police Department]

The Central Park Five subsequently sued the city of New York, and ended up winning $41 million in a settlement in 2014.

But were they truly exonerated? Experts are divided. Some blamed racism for the convictions. Others pointed the finger at the media circus and hysteria surrounding the events of that night.

A 2012 Ken Burns documentary The Central Park Five presented analysis to suggest that police should have connected Reyes to the attack at the time it happened rather than focusing on the five teens.

In videotaped confessions, the suspects described details of the assault. District Attorney Robert M. Morgenthau's office wrote:

“A comparison of the statements reveals troubling discrepancies. The accounts given by the five defendants differed from one another on the specific details of virtually every major aspect of the crime — who initiated the attack, who knocked the victim down, who undressed her, who struck her, who held her, who raped her, what weapons were used in the course of the assault, and when in the sequence of events the attack took place."

The suspects later claimed that the confessions were coerced, but Michael Armstrong, who served on a panel re-investigating the case, wrote in the Wall Street Journal that there is no evidence of this claim. Recently, the five men, now middle-aged, are pushing for legislation that would require videotaping of all questioning of suspects by police, for the entirety of the time a suspect is in custody.

In the Central Park Five case, only the boys' confessions were recorded, but the 24 to 36 hours of questioning, during which time it's reported that no food or water was provided, were not. Many feel that the confessions were obtained under duress, and that the authorities fed information to the boys.

Some observers maintain that the Central Park Five did actually attack Meili, but then afterward Reyes proceeded to rape her.

Back in 1989, Donald Trump took out full-page ads in New York newspapers against the Central Park Five and calling for the reinstitution of the death penalty in New York state. During his presidential campaign, Trump expressed his opinion that the convictions should never have been vacated.

In response to Trump's widely proclaimed views on the case, Salaam said, “He believed (the prosecutors) had so much evidence in the case, when they didn’t have any evidence. Heroes are ones who are able to say, ‘I’m sorry, I rushed to judgment.’ (Trump) hasn’t offered that.”

Photo by: Book cover art [Scribner/Amazon]

Book cover art [Scribner/Amazon]

In April 2003, Meili confirmed her identity to the media and published a memoir entitled I Am the Central Park Jogger. She revealed that she still suffers from after effects of the attack, including memory loss. Meili, who lives in Jacksonville, Florida, now gives motivational speeches in which she shares her story of survival with others.

In 2018, documents and images related to the case were released to the public by the New York City Law Department. Meili has expressed appreciation about having access to the materials, as she believes they can help her piece her memory of that night back together.

She has also recently stated to 20/20 that she's not so sure that Reyes is the only assailant responsible for her attack. Her doctors reportedly told her that the damage to her body was consistent with more than one attacker, even to the point of displaying handprints of different sizes.

"I so wish the case hadn't been settled," Meili said on the show. Former New York City detective Eric Reynolds reportedly still believes the original five are responsible, and has said, "The five of them went to Central Park to beat up people and they ended up with millions of dollars and they’re heroes and civil rights icons."

Next Up

Pics Of Nude Women Found In Storage Unit Of Former Gyno Accused Of Sexual Assault

Nearly 100 women who claim that they were sexually harassed by Dr. George Tyndall announced in October that they planned to sue the school.

'Making A Murderer': Here's Everything We Know About Season One

A new season of Making a Murderer, the Netflix series that told the story of convicted murderer Steven Avery, is starting on October 19.

Florida Teen Raped His Neighbor At Knifepoint; Offered To Do Yard Work To Make Up For It

Timothy Walding, who was wearing a mask, broke into his victim's home at around 4 A.M. and entered her bedroom.

Police Collect DNA From Male Employees After Woman In A Coma For 14 Years Gives Birth

The 29-year-old Native American woman was a patient at Hacienda HealthCare center in Phoenix.

School Bus Driver Who Admitted To Raping 14-Year-Old Girl Gets No Jail Time

As part of a plea deal, Shane Piche got 10 years probation and must register as a sex offender.

Florida Man Allegedly Told Underage Battery Victim He Was 'Instagram Famous'

Richard Brown, 25, also reportedly lured the girl from Texas and paid for her $822 Uber ride to Florida.

Is Samuel Little America's Most Prolific Serial Killer With Up To 90 Murders?

By comparison, Gary Ridgway, the infamous Green River Killer, is currently considered the country’s worst serial killer following his conviction for murdering 49 victims in Washington during the 1980s and ’90s.

Raymond Dean Holley, Wanted For Alleged Easter Sunday Child Sex Abuse, Captured

He's accused of molesting two little girls in his care on Easter Sunday 2018.

Judge: Teen Who Showed Sex Tape To Friends Must Register As Sex Offender For 25 Years

Jeremiah Horton, 18, was reportedly also sentenced to six months in a rehab facility for nonviolent felony offenders.