Elderly Arkansas Farmer Accused Of Leaving Dead Animals On Late Neighbor’s Grave

The alleged culprit reportedly disguised himself as a woman to evade detection.

August 17, 2020

Joseph A. Stroud [KNWA]

Joseph A. Stroud [KNWA]

By: Aaron Rasmussen

A farmer from Bentonville, Arkansas, was recently taken into custody for allegedly causing over $2,500 in damage to a headstone by repeatedly tossing dead animals on his late neighbor’s grave.

According to a probable cause report, Joseph A. Stroud, 78, first came under suspicion after the family of Fred Allen McKinney, who died at age 94 on August 24, 2015, went on a mission to figure out why the carcasses suddenly began appearing in May, Northwest Arkansas’ KNWA-TV reported.

“At first, they thought it was just a coincidence and thought maybe the animals were consuming the fake floral and dying,” the report states. “When they began finding more dead animals, they realized it wasn’t just a coincidence, someone was placing the dead animals there purposefully.”

Family removed approximately 16 carcasses from the grave, according to the report. McKinney’s granddaughter, Shannon Nobles, told Pea Ridge police that on one occasion she found a dead possum on the grave and eight live baby possums stuffed in a flower vase flanking the headstone.

Family requested permission to set up video surveillance in the cemetery and eventually caught on camera an individual approach “the headstone with a dead animal in hand, place the dead animal on the headstone, and walk back to his vehicle,” a gray Dodge Journey, the probable cause report states.

Police said the images showed what appeared to be a male disguised in a gray wig and sunglasses wearing blue slip-on shoes with white soles and a woman’s windbreaker over denim overalls.

Nobles, who twice spotted a gray Dodge Journey departing the cemetery, was able to help crack the case when on one occasion she tailed the vehicle to the parking lot of a Walmart, where she recognized Stroud as the driver.

Police compared video and photos from the unidentified culprit at the cemetery with Stroud at Walmart and saw both were wearing the same blue slip-on shoes.

When they went to Stroud’s residence, investigators said they observed through a window what “appeared to be blood” on a bath towel in the back of the suspect’s 2018 Dodge Journey.

Stroud has denied he had anything to do with leaving the dead animals on McKinney’s grave.

According to the probable cause report, Stroud and McKinney “had farms next to each other with a shared boundary for several years.”

Nobles told investigators the two men “never got along with each other” and she claimed Stroud may have once lost a lawsuit with her late grandfather.

Stroud faces a felony charge of defacing objects of public respect.

Next Up

Texas Murder Suspect’s Tiger Taken Into Custody After Disappearing For Nearly One Week

The male feline, named India, was 9 months old and already weighed 175 pounds.

Help Us Find Accused Child Molester Mark Randall Blevins From Victoria, TX

This is a case brought to the show in December 2020 by law enforcement through the "In Pursuit with John Walsh" Facebook page. If you have any information on where Mark Blevins is hiding out, please do not hesitate to call or text our hotline directly: 833-378-7783 (3-PURSUE).

Independent Probe Of Elijah McClain’s Death Accuses Police, Paramedics Of Wrongdoing

Aurora, Colorado, law enforcement officials “failed to ask basic, critical questions about the justification for the use of force,” panel’s report claims.

Elderly Vietnam Vet Thwarts Suspect in South Carolina Home Invasion

“He was not going to go out that door and leave us alive,” recalls 82-year-old Herbert Parrish.

New York Man Convicted Of Illegally Raising Sharks In 18-Foot Basement Pool

Investigators found seven sandbar sharks, a protected species, as well as several other dead fish.

Human Trafficking Survivor And FBI Agent Team Up To Save Victims

Thousands of Americans become the victim of human trafficking each year. This survivor is speaking out and fighting back.

Felony Charges Dropped Against 12-Year-Old Student With Autism

“This is a national issue where we're criminalizing behavior of people with intellectual disabilities,” the child’s mother warns.

Inside The Mysterious Disappearance of Christina Whittaker

In 2009, the 21-year-old vanished without a trace from Hannibal, Missouri. Filmmaker Christina Fontana pledges to find the truth about her disappearance.

Tejano Music Queen Selena Was Shot To Death By The President Of Her Fan Club

As Selena ran from the room, Yolanda Saldivar shot her in the back. Selena died in a hospital due to a loss of blood and cardiac arrest, two weeks before her 24th birthday.

College Student Dies Under Mysterious Circumstances After Uber Driver Brings Her To Hospital

Ciaya Jordan Whetstone was out with friends in New Orleans celebrating Mardi Gras hours before her death.