Will There Finally Be Justice For Megan McDonald?

College student Megan McDonald was murdered in March 2003. 20 years later, a suspect was finally arrested in connection with her case but released one week later due to a legal error.

April 28, 2023
Megan McDonald, pictured here smiling, was discovered brutally beaten to death on March 15, 2003 in Wallkill, New York.

College student Megan McDonald was murdered in March 2003. 20 years later, there may be justice in her case.

Photo by: New York State Police

New York State Police

At around 1 p.m. on March 15, 2003, a man discovered the body of a young woman in a secluded spot just off Bowser Road in Wallkill, New York. Investigators soon discovered it was the body of 20-year-old SUNY Orange student Megan McDonald. She had been badly beaten and died from blunt force trauma, and the tragedy unfortunately became a cold case.

The mystery started on March 13, which is believed to be Megan’s last full day alive. According to the Justice for Megan website, she worked until around 3 p.m. at American Cafe in the Galleria mall, and she was seen withdrawing cash at her bank about 10 minutes later. She was seen again at 7 p.m. when she drove by a party at Greenway Terrace. She had friends there who invited her to stay, but she decided to hang out with other friends in Middletown. She hung out with those friends from around 7:30 p.m. to midnight watching a Friends marathon and then left, saying she had to get up early for work the next day.

At 12:15 a.m. on March 14, instead of going home, Megan returned to the party at Greenway. Terrace, but she never went inside. Nobody police interviewed knows why she went there, but she was last seen driving away from the party. Fifteen minutes later, she was seen driving into the parking lot of Kensington Manor apartments, and she was followed by someone driving a dark hatchback that had blaring music that could be heard from a distance. The cars drove in a circle in the parking lot twice, then the witness lost track of them.

Nobody ever saw Megan alive again after that. Her body was discovered the next afternoon. USA Today reported that her family laid her to rest with a heart-shaped gravestone in the St. Joseph's Church cemetery in Middletown, New York.

Police conducted a thorough investigation in which they did dozens of interviews and followed over 800 leads in the case. The initial investigators carefully kept custody of the evidence with the insight that forensic tools would advance and perhaps lead to answers.

Megan’s family never gave up seeking justice for her. Although her father, a former NYPD homicide detective, died a few months before she did, her mother and sister sought answers for 20 years. Rewards were offered, but the case went cold.

On April 20, 2023, the New York State Police arrested 42-year-old Edward V. Holley for second degree murder in connection with McDonald’s murder. He would have been in his twenties at the time of the murder. He had been dating Megan, and they broke up shortly before her murder.

In a turn of events that shocked the public, authorities released Holley shortly after his arrest because the law stated that he had to be indicted within six days of his arrest. According to NBC New York, standard protocol wasn’t followed for Orange County criminal cases, and the district attorney’s office didn’t know about the arrest.

NBC New York reported that Orange County District Attorney David Hoovler said, "The family of the victim, and the entire community, deserve to have homicide cases handled in the best way possible to provide the greatest opportunity for offenders to be held accountable."

Hoovler also revealed that the district attorney’s office is prioritizing the investigation and a special prosecutor will oversee the prosecution. The case hasn’t yet gone to a grand jury, but it’s expected to soon.

In the aftermath of Holley’s release, McDonald’s family released a statement through their lawyer John P. Beatty which was posted on the Justice for Megan website. They said, "Our family is disappointed. However, his temporary release was expected. After patiently waiting for over 20 years, we are confident that the police have arrested the right person - Edward Holley. The process may not be easy or follow our preferred path, but we will not rest until justice is secured for Megan."

Beatty added, “My office will leave no stone unturned in ensuring that the prosecution of Edward Holley now proceeds expeditiously, professionally, and ethically. We remain committed to seeking justice for Megan and holding those responsible accountable for their actions.”

Next Up

True Crime News Roundup: Iowa Teenagers Allegedly Killed Spanish Teacher Over Bad Grades

Plus: Gabby Petito’s parents file lawsuit against Utah police; Handyman admits to killing New York mom; Massachusetts ‘Lady of the Dunes’ identified; Long-haul trucker accused of murdering girlfriend.

‘Why Did They Do This To Him?’ Mother Mourns NYC College Student Who Died From Hazing Ritual

Chun Hsien “Michael” Deng suffered a traumatic brain injury when he was blindfolded and tackled.

Many Furious As Oklahoma Death Row Inmate Set To Be Executed In May

Richard Glossip has eaten three last meals as he awaited three different executions for a murder he insists he had no involvement in.

Man Sentenced For Beating College Student To Death With A Piano Leg

On Sept. 20, 2004, Rebekah Gould, 22, answered the door to a man who asked to use her phone. A week later, her body was found dumped on the side of the road. Her case went cold for over a decade and a half.

Police Seek Possible Witnesses To 22-Year-Old Brooklyn Woman’s Murder

On Sept. 21, 2022, police responding to reports of a foul odor at a Brooklyn, New York apartment found the dismembered remains of 22-year-old D'Asia Johnson stuffed into a suitcase.

5 Questions The Gabby Petito Case Brought Up About Domestic Violence

The murder of 22-year-old Gabby Petito at the hands of her boyfriend, Brian Laundrie, sparked a national conversation about the signs of domestic abuse.

What We Know About The Suspect Arrested In Murders Of Four Idaho College Students

On Dec. 30, 2022, Bryan Kohberger was arrested in connection with the November murders of Madison Mogen, Kaylee Goncalves, Xana Kernodle, and Ethan Chapin.

The Brutal Murders Of Four Idaho College Students Remain A Mystery

On Nov. 13, 2022, four University of Idaho college students were murdered in their home, while two of their roommates were left unharmed. Police don’t yet have suspects or answers in this mysterious mass killing.

Man Accused Of Murdering Grad Student In L.A. Furniture Store Indicted On New Charges

In January 2022, Shawn Laval Smith allegedly attacked 24-year-old Brianna Kupfer after he entered the business where she was working alone, police say.

Former Pastor Charged After Confessing To Abducting, Killing 8-Year-Old Girl In 1975

The 1975 disappearance and murder of 8-year-old Gretchen Harrington remained a devastating mystery for her family and loved ones for nearly five decades until July 2023 when an arrest was finally made.