Case Of Couple Who Vanished From Manhattan Apartment In 1997 Remains A Mystery

Did a feud with a landlord lead to the disappearance of Camden Sylvia and Michael Sullivan? If you have any information about this mystery, please contact Senior Investigator Robert Delaney with the Manhattan District Attorney's Office: (212) 335-8957.

December 28, 2022
Michael Sullivan, 54, (left) and Camden Sylvia, 36, (right) went missing from their Manhattan apartment on Nov. 7, 1997.

On Nov. 7, 1997, 36-year-old Camden Sylvia and 54-year-old Michael Sullivan vanished from their Manhattan apartment.

Photo by: Manhattan District Attorney's Office

Manhattan District Attorney's Office

By: Crimefeed Contributor

On Nov. 7, 1997, 36-year-old Camden Sylvia and 54-year-old Michael Sullivan vanished from their Manhattan apartment. They left their belongings behind, including their keys, wallet, and a video they rented earlier on in the day. The couple wasn’t formally reported missing until after the weekend, according to authorities.

According to WPIX, Sylvia and Sullivan had a great deal on their loft in the Wall Street district. Because this area was rent controlled, the couple was only required to pay $304 a month.

In November 2022, Joel Seidemann, a prosecutor with the Manhattan District Attorney's Office, spoke to WPIX for a story about the 25-year mystery. He provided more information and shed more light on the disappearance. The couple wanted their landlord, Robert Rodriguez, to provide heat, something he may not have been willing to do. Seidemann said, “The tenants (Syliva and Sullivan) had put together a letter. They said they intended engaging in a rent strike if he did not, and Michael Sullivan was supposed to deliver the letter that day.”

According to WPIX, authorities wanted to question Rodriguez, but he reportedly disappeared for 10 days.

Although Rodriguez has previously denied any wrongdoing, authorities confirmed he did vanish for a long stretch of time early on in the investigation. In 2017, WPIX reported the investigation into Rodriguez about Syliva and Sullivan, uncovered other crimes. WPIX said, "The investigation of Robert Rodriguez eventually led to other criminal charges, with Rodriguez convicted of identity theft (he was convicted of using the ID of a dead man), credit card fraud and tax evasion." The report goes on to say Rodriguez spent time behind bars for his convictions and was released in 2004.

Camden’s mother Laurie, who is now 81-years-old, says she has hope and does what she can to keep her daughter's memory alive.“I don’t have that long to live. I’m 81 years old. I’d like to go to bed one night knowing what happened.”

Seidemann added, “Somebody out there who knows something... who can put us over the finish line.”

If you have any information about this Manhattan mystery, please contact Senior Investigator Robert Delaney with the Manhattan District Attorney's Office: (212) 335-8957.

Next Up

In 1989, Two Toddlers Vanished From The Same NYC Park Three Months Apart

Two-year-old Christopher "Choo Choo" Dansby and 19-month-old Shane Walker vanished without a trace. If you have any information about these children, please contact The National Center for Missing and Exploited Children.

A New York Socialite Vanished Without A Trace In December 1910

Dorothy Harriet Camille Arnold was the heir to a perfume fortune when she vanished without a trace on Dec. 12, 1910. Her case is the oldest missing person file listed with The Charley Project, a public database of more than 15,000 missing people.

Questions Surround 2 Separate Cases Of 3 People Found Dead After Going Missing In California

Former couple Janette Pantoja and Juan Almanza Zavala and teenager Kiely Rodni vanished within hours of each other in Nevada County.

Ex-Boyfriend Of Missing Nebraska Mother Arrested In Central America

Cari Allen, 43, was reported missing on Nov. 20, 2022. Over two weeks later, on Dec. 6, 2022, her ex-boyfriend, 47-year-old Aldrick Scott, was apprehended in Belize and arrested in connection with her disappearance.

A Georgia Mom Left For The Store In 2021 And Never Returned

Tiffany Foster’s fiancé was later charged with moving her car after she went missing, but he has not been charged with anything else relating to her March 2021 disappearance.

Golden Gate Bridge Mystery: Where's Sydney West?

The Find Sydney West website, dedicated to finding the missing 19-year-old, announced a $25,000 reward to help find her. Sydney stands 5 feet 10 inches tall and weighs around 130 pounds.

Headless, Handless Body Found In 1980 Was Finally Identified Over Four Decades Later

On March 20, 1980, police in Fishkill, New York found a decapitated and handless body. 42 years later, the body was identified as 44-year-old Manhattan woman Anna L. Papalardo-Blake.

Two Texas Teens Left After Curfew In 1988 And Never Returned

Police in Carrollton, Texas, initially thought Stacie Madison and Susan Smalley were runaways.

A Woman Disappeared From A Group Hike And Was Never Seen Again

65-year-old Patricia Ann Krieger was hiking with her fiancé and several of his family members when they said she disappeared down the wrong trail.

Missing High School Senior Found Dead After Classmates Organize Search

“It didn’t make sense, and someone needed to figure out where he was,” a teacher at 18-year-old Amara Jones’ school says.