Two Texas Teens Left After Curfew In 1988 And Never Returned

Police in Carrollton, Texas, initially thought Stacie Madison and Susan Smalley were runaways.

February 02, 2023
Susan Smalley [left] and Stacie Madison [right] went missing from Addison, Texas on March 19, 1988.

Teenagers Susan Smalley and Stacie Madison went missing from Addison, Texas on March 19, 1988. The car in which the girls were traveling was recovered in Carrollton, Texas, on March 22, 1988 but the girls have never been found.

Photo by: NCMEC


Two teens from Carrollton, Texas, should be adults making plans to attend their 35th high school reunion this year. Instead, they are the subject of a decades-old cold case with few answers.

On March 19, 1988, Stacie Madison, 17, was spending time with her best friend, 18-year-old Susan Smalley. The girls were seniors at Newman Smith High School in Carrollton, a suburb north of Dallas. Spring break was almost over, and the girls were planning a sleepover at Susan’s house, according to NBC News.

Stacie drove a 1967 Mustang convertible painted the colors of their high school, and she picked Susan up that night to stop in and pick Susan’s mother up from her job at a department store.

According to The Doe Project, the girls eventually went to see an apartment full of friends in Arlington, another Dallas-area suburb about 25 miles from Carrollton. The pair also stopped in at the restaurant where Susan worked as a waitress. Stacie stayed in the vehicle while Susan went inside around 11:30 p.m. Some accounts of the evening report that the girls attempted to purchase alcohol at a 7-11 store before they arrived at the restaurant.

The girls made their midnight curfew and called Stacie’s mom to check in from Susan’s house. It was the last time anybody heard from the girls. It was unknown when the two left again, but their family members began to worry on March 21 and reported the girls as missing. The next day, March 22, Stacie’s Mustang was found in the parking of Webb Chapel Village on Forest Lane in Dallas, Texas. Forest Lane was a cruising strip that was a popular hangout spot for teens in the area, according to Stacie’s sister, Stefanie. The girls’ personal belongings were inside the car, including a portable stereo.

In 2020, family members told NBC that police initially treated the disappearance as a case of runaways trying to extend spring break and that the delay had catastrophic consequences on law enforcement’s ability to investigate the case.

The case is the subject of a 2009 book, This Night Wounds Time: The Mysterious Disappearances of Stacie Madison and Susan Smalley, written by Shawn Sutherland, a fellow Newman Smith student who performed his own independent investigation into the case. While the book reportedly generated new leads, police are no closer to solving the mystery than they were in 1988.

If Stacie and Susan are still alive, they would be 52 and 53 years old. At the time they went missing, Stacie was 5’6” and weighed 160 pounds. Susan was 5’8 and weighed 140 pounds.

If you have any information about Stacie Madison or Susan Smalley, please contact the Carrollton Police Department at 214-466-3324.

Next Up

Mystery Remains After 13-Year-Old Girl Vanished From A Minnesota Gas Station In 1989

“You still kind of wait for the phone call for someone to say, ‘We found her, she's coming home,’” the mother of Amy Sue Pagnac says.

Sam Tapp Vanished In 2004, Sisters Release Touching Letters In Hopes Of Reaching Her

Authorities said Sam Tapp went missing from Burleson, Texas in 2004. According to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children (NCMEC) she may use the alias last name Vandiver. If you have any information on where Sam could be, please contact NCMEC directly: 1-800-THE-LOST.

Have You Seen Semaj Goodwine? Georgia Teen Vanished In South Carolina

On March 7, 2021, 16-year-old Semaj Goodwine disappeared from his aunt’s house in the dead of night.

What Happened To Tonetta Carlisle? Authorities Say Teen Was Abducted From Tennessee

Tonetta Carlisle was last seen being forced into a vehicle in Chattanooga on March 16, 1989. If you know anything about Tonetta's case, please contact the Chattanooga Police directly: 423-698-2525.

Have You Seen Asha Degree? Missing Since Valentine's Day 2000

Investigators said Asha Degree vanished from her North Carolina home in 2000. Her family says the then fourth grader packed a bag and left in the middle of the night without her coat.

5 Things That Still Bother Us About The Unsolved Maura Murray Case

On Feb. 9, 2004, UMass Amherst student Maura Murray left campus and crashed her car in Haverhill, New Hampshire. She has never been seen since.

Golden Gate Bridge Mystery: Where's Sydney West?

The Find Sydney West website, dedicated to finding the missing 19-year-old, announced a $25,000 reward to help find her. Sydney stands 5 feet 10 inches tall and weighs around 130 pounds.

Questions Surround 2 Separate Cases Of 3 People Found Dead After Going Missing In California

Former couple Janette Pantoja and Juan Almanza Zavala and teenager Kiely Rodni vanished within hours of each other in Nevada County.

Teen Lashaya Stine Is Missing; Her Mom Fears Sex Trafficking

“She needs to try and get away from whatever it is. If she can get to me, I will protect her. I will do anything to protect her,” her mother, Sabrina Jones, emphasizes.

‘He Was Speaking Truth To Power’: Questions Remain In Case Of Chicano Activist Found Dead

UC Davis student Oscar Gomez died from blunt force trauma in 1994 and his manner of death was listed as undetermined.