Unsavory Surprise: Executive Embezzles Almost $17 Million From Famous Fruitcake Bakery

Sandy Jenkins and his wife Kay’s lavish spending sprees included getting a new luxury vehicle “every time they needed an oil change,” prosecutors say.

November 29, 2021
Kay and Sandy Jenkins smiling on a private plane in front of a white and brown background. Kay (left) wears a black top. Sandy (right) wears a light blue collard shirt.

Kay and Sandy Jenkins pleaded guilty to charges related to embezzling $16.7 million from Collin Street Bakery.

Photo by: Facebook

Facebook

Kay and Sandy Jenkins pleaded guilty to charges related to embezzling $16.7 million from Collin Street Bakery.

By: Aaron Rasmussen

While the Grinch may have tried to steal Christmas, an employee at a world-famous fruitcake bakery managed to gobble up millions of dollars in profits in what turned out to be a massive embezzlement scheme.

Beginning around December 2004, prosecutors said Sandy Jenkins began defrauding Collin Street Bakery, a business based in Corsicana, Texas, that sells as many as 20,000 fruitcakes a day during the busy holiday season.

Over the course of the next nearly nine years, Jenkins, who began his job as corporate controller for the bakery in 1998 and reportedly earned around $50,000 a year, embezzled $16,766,645.70 by issuing 888 fraudulent checks.

Jenkins had access to company checks and would write them out to his personal creditors, according to the Waco Tribune-Herald. In order to balance the books and evade detection, he voided the checks in the accounting system but used them anyway. He then wrote new checks in the same amounts to legitimate vendors but never sent them.

Jenkins’ wife, Kay, helped him spend the stolen funds. Prosecutors noted she never spoke with him about the scheme and turned a blind eye to their sudden wealth, the Corsicana Daily Sun reported.

Evidence detailed in court papers against the couple show the lavishness of their lifestyle as they blew through the bakery’s money over the years.

According to officials, the couple doled out over $3.3 million to take 223 trips on private jets to Santa Fe, Aspen, Napa and other destinations across the country.

They purchased 38 new vehicles, from a Lexus and Mercedes-Benz to a Bentley and Porsche, “every time they needed an oil change,” prosecutors said.

Sandy and Kay were especially beloved by Neiman Marcus employees in Dallas, where the two spent over $1 million and had the nicknames “Fruitcake” and “Cupcake.” Citing government evidence, prosecutors said the Jenkins were such good customers they had to stop shopping at the high-end department store because “Neiman’s ran out of things to sell them.”

The bulk of the ill-gotten money, $11 million or almost $100,000 per month, was spent to pay off the pair’s Black American Express Card as they stocked up on Rolex watches, jewelry, designer clothing and other luxury items.

Jenkins was fired in June 2013 after an accountant at Collin Street Bakery noticed discrepancies in the books and uncovered the embezzlement scheme.

Sandy pleaded guilty the following year to one count of mail fraud, one count of conspiracy to commit money laundering, and one count of making a false statement to a financial institution. A judge sentenced him to 120 months in federal prison.

Kay pleaded guilty to one count of conspiracy to commit money laundering, and she was ordered to complete 100 of community service, write a letter of apology to the bakery, and serve five years of probation.

The government recovered roughly $4,000,000 in cash and property of the almost $17 million the Jenkins spent. The couple was ordered to pay Collins Street Bakery restitution jointly in the amount of $12,697,921.79.

For more on this story, start streaming Fruitcake Fraud Dec. 1 on discovery+. This documentary takes viewers to the heart of the small town rocked by the scam.

Next Up

The 2012 Murder Of Radio Host April Kauffman

Dr. James Kauffman offered a motorcycle gang leader $50,000 and unlimited Oxycontin prescriptions to murder his wife, April, who was suing him for divorce.

Undercover Cop Uses Alter Ego ‘Missy’ To Capture Suspected Wife Killer

“I came in like a fresh friend,” Joan Bauer says of getting Philip Snider to open up during their chats over coffee at Burger King.

5 Things To Know About Con-Man-Turned-Pastor Barry Minkow

Barry Minkow has been a prisoner, a pastor, and a few things in between.

True Crime News Roundup: Elderly Man Missing For Months Found Dead In Trash Can Outside His Home

Plus: NYC sixth-grader struck and killed by stray bullet; New Hampshire police search for person of interest in double homicide; Fyre Festival fraudster released early from prison; and manhunt continues for escaped Texas prisoner.

Deadly Dads: 5 Fathers Who Killed Their Own Kids

Give your dad a call this Father’s Day … and give thanks you weren’t born to one of these monsters.

Death, Drugs & Deceit: A Timeline of the Murdaugh Family Mystery

Alex Murdaugh found his wife and son murdered in June 2021, but his troubles started years earlier.

DNA Kit Helps Reunite Mom With Daughter She Thought Died At Birth Almost 70 Years Ago

The pair’s first meeting was a “bawlfest” and led to some exciting new revelations for both.

A West Virginia Mother Blamed Her 11-Year-Old For Husband’s Murder

When authorities arrived at a home where a man had been shot, the story they heard didn’t quite add up.

Mother-Of-Four Shot Dead After Ex-Husband Hires Brother To Kill Her, FBI Says

The siblings are both in custody over four years after elementary school teacher Sara Starr was found dead in her driveway.