New Leads In The 1988 Abduction Of Polaroid Mystery Teen Tara Calico — Can You Help?

June 26, 2018
By: Mike McPadden

Related To:

Mystery Polaroid that might depict Tara Calico and an unknown boy

Mystery Polaroid that might depict Tara Calico and an unknown boy

Photo by: Polaroid found in Port St. Joe, Florida in 1989 [Valencia County Sheriff's Department]

Polaroid found in Port St. Joe, Florida in 1989 [Valencia County Sheriff's Department]

BELEN, NM — At 9:30 A.M. on September 20, 1988, 19-year-old Tara Calico announced she was going to ride her pink Huffy mountain bike along a 17-mile course before returning home and getting ready for a noon tennis date with her boyfriend.

Tara then pedaled off and was never seen again — until perhaps June 1989, when a terrifying Polaroid turned up in a supermarket parking lot nearly 1,600 miles away in Port St. Joe, Florida.

The photograph depicted a teenage female and a young boy of about 10 staring into the camera. The hands of each victim were bound behind their backs and duct tape was stretched across their mouths.

Print and broadcast media shared the picture massively hoping for leads. Back in New Mexico, Patty Doel, Tara’s mom, thought that she recognized her daughter. The boy’s identity, alas, still remains a mystery.

In the original Polaroid, Tara and the boy are lying on a bed that appears to be in the back of a van or other vehicle. The novel My Sweet Audrina by V.C. Andrews is next to Tara. Andrews was her favorite author.

Witnesses said that a white Toyota cargo van had been parked in the area where the Polaroid turned up. The driver appeared to be a white male with a mustache in his 30s. Neither the van nor the driver has ever been identified.

Now, after 30 years of loved ones and authorities working tirelessly to track down the truth about Tara and the boy, both the FBI and the Valencia County Sheriffs are actively examining at least two living suspects, and detectives even have a theory as to what may have happened.

Talking to People magazine, chief investigator Sgt. Joseph Rowland and former Valencia County Sheriff Rene Rivera say a pair of informants have pointed law enforcement toward some promising possibilities.

Both Rowland and Rivera think Tara may have known her perpetrator. Rivera goes on to propose that she could have been killed by two local teenage boys who may have acted with two other accomplices.

Rivera also cites a theory that two boys riding in a pickup truck crossed paths with Tara on her bicycle before attacking her.

The former sheriff says that the boys' parents would have helped them cover up the crime, and that he believes Tara is likely buried somewhere in Valencia County.

Not finding the body, Rivera adds, continues to make it difficult to file charges.

In addition to the flurry of activity by legal authorities, a podcast titled Vanished: The Tara Calico Investigation has generated much new public interest in the case.

Melinda Esquibel, a high school friend of Tara’s who now works as a filmmaker, created and hosts the podcast. Citing the nature of Tara’s close-knit railroad community of Belen, Esquibel echoes Rivera’s notion that the abductors’ families would cover for them, saying:

“What makes the town charming is the same thing that makes it kind of scary — that you will go to great lengths to protect your own … There’s a lot of people that don’t want this case solved.”

Esquibel and Tara’s stepsister have kept the investigation on fire through grassroots activism and amateur sleuthing.

Doel told People that she’s seeking the facts, but she also longs for Tara to have justice, stating:

“I want to know where she’s at. … But I also want somebody to pay for it and, whether they’re alive or dead, at least acknowledge the fact that it happened.”

If you have any information about Tara Calico’s disappearance, contact the Valencia County Sheriff’s Office at (505) 866-2400 or the FBI at 1 (800) CALL-FBI or online at tips.fbi.gov.

Next Up

Kayla Unbehaun, Missing Since 2017, Found Safe In Asheville

Kayla Unbehaun was abducted from Illinois by her biological mother, Heather Unbehaun, on Independence Day 2017. 6 years later, she was found safe in North Carolina.

Where Is Amanda Nicole Eileen Campbell? The 4-Year-Old’s Bike Was Found But She Never Was

Authorities still don’t know what happened to a 4-year-old California girl who disappeared in 1991.

Family Still Looking For Answers In 1965 Disappearance Of Elizabeth Gill

Authorities said a vehicle previously purchased in Lake Orion, Michigan is linked to this Cape Girardeau, Missouri mystery. If you have any information on this missing mystery, please contact the Cape Girardeau Police Department directly: 573-335-6621.

Anthonette Cayedito Vanished In Middle Of Night, Last Seen Wearing Pink Nightgown

The 9-year-old went missing from her New Mexico childhood home in 1986. If you have any information on where Anthonette Cayedito could be, please call the FBI directly: 505-889-1300.

Child Who Went Missing From A Washington Mall In 2018 Found Safe In Mexico

8-year-old Aranza Maria Ochoa Lopez, who had been missing since 2018, was found alive and well in Mexico and returned to the United States.

Man Arrested After Ring Camera Captures Attempted Abduction Of 6-Year-Old Girl

33-year-old Deric McPherson was arrested on Aug. 23, 2022 after grabbing a 6-year-old girl and attempting to pull her down the sidewalk with him.

Amber Alert Canceled After Abducted 13-Year-Old Girl Escapes Kidnapper

A 13-year-old girl was kidnapped from her home in Reading, Pennsylvania on Aug. 31, 2022. Later that day, the girl was found over a hundred miles away.

Two Kidnapped Children Found Nearly One Year Later In Florida Supermarket

In February 2023, a routine vehicle tag check near a Winn-Dixie supermarket helped police locate the alleged kidnapper, 36-year-old Kristi Nicole Gilley, inside the store with the two children.

Kidnapping Victim Helps Orchestrate Her Own Rescue By Holding Up Sign Saying 'Help Me'

A 13-year-old girl was rescued after holding up a sign from the window of Steven Robert Sablan’s car in a Long Beach, California parking lot.

Tara Calico, Missing Since 1988, Might Have Been Spotted In A Mysterious Polaroid

Tara Calico's last words to her mother were, “Mom, if I'm not back by 12, come look for me."