Skeletal Remains Found In 1991 Finally Identified As Young Ohio Man

After 31 years, skeletal remains found in a shallow grave in Pickaway County, Ohio have been identified as Robert A. Mullins who was 21 at the time of his disappearance.

December 29, 2022
The remains of Robert A. Mullins, pictured here, were originally found on Nov. 1, 1991 but only identified in December 2022.

The remains of Robert A. Mullins were originally found on Nov. 1, 1991 near a farm in central Ohio but only identified as Mullins in December 2022.

Photo by: Pickaway County Sheriff's Office

Pickaway County Sheriff's Office

On Nov. 1, 1991, hunters discovered skeletal remains that had been placed in a shallow grave near a private farm in Pickaway County, Ohio. For three decades, the identity of the deceased individual went unsolved.

On Dec. 13, 2022, Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost joined Pickaway County Sheriff Matthew O. Hafey to announce that the body was identified as Robert A. Mullins. He had gone missing in late 1988 or early 1989 when he was 21 years old and living on the northeast side of Columbus, Ohio.

“Thirty-one Christmases have gone by while this family waited for answers. When the results weren’t immediate and the case grew cool, Pickaway County law enforcement dug in their heels and kept trying until the evolution of DNA technology finally yielded an identity for John Doe,” Yost said, reported The Washington Post.

The journey to identifying Mullins involved multiple investigators with the sheriff’s and coroner’s offices who worked hard on the case over the years, and they used DNA technology as it advanced. In 2012, the body was identified as male with DNA testing. In 2019, an unidentified human remains case was opened, and DNA was taken from the original bones for more advanced testing.

Then, in 2021, investigators worked to solve the mystery with a focus on genetic genealogy. In January 2022, they contracted with AdvanceDNA which uploaded the DNA profile into Family Tree DNA and GEDmatch databases. Finally in Dec. 2022, the victim’s family were consulted, and his remains were positively identified after they provided a DNA sample.

“We’re all going to die at some point – it’s the one thing that’s certain about our lives on this earth, but what a tragedy to die unknown – to not have a name to put on a memorial. Today, that circle closes. And that’s the first step on the rest of justice,” Yost said, according to CNN.

Investigators believe that Mullins was likely a victim of homicide and now his murder remains an unsolved mystery. The case is now an open homicide investigation with the Pickaway County Sheriff’s Office. If you have any information about the disappearance and murder, please contact Lt. Jonathan Strawser at 740-474-2176.

Next Up

Texas Man Murdered Woman After He Took Her Out On Date To Concert

Erika Andrea Gaytan appeared happy when she posted on social media from the event in El Paso.

California Man Texted 911 For Help Before Vanishing In 2021, His Remains Have Now Been Found

Beau Mann texted 911 for help from his Uber in November 2021, and was never heard from again. Nearly a year and a half later, his body was found at an abandoned property in the Los Angeles area.

Man Arrested After Missing Texas Woman Madeline Molina Pantoja Found Dead

A 21-year-old Texas woman was last heard arguing with a man on May 10, and she was never seen again. Nine days after she was reported missing, her remains were found in a rural area.

Inside Alcatraz: How 3 Inmates Broke Out Of ‘The Rock’ — A Prison Once Considered Inescapable

A convicted armed robber and bank-robbing brothers spent months planning their daring flight to freedom.

5 Things To Know About Lori Vallow And The Investigation Into The Death Of Her Children

The Idaho mom’s son and daughter disappeared without a trace in September 2019. Their remains were found buried in shallow graves in June 2020.

Mystery Remains Decades After Hawaii Teen Lisa Au Was Found Dead In 1982

The 19-year-old was an ‘ideal young lady’ and daughter who ‘you’d never think this would happen to,’ a former investigator says.

Police Believe Florida Man May Have Killed 3 Women He Once Dated

‘He is the devil,’ says the daughter of one of suspect Cleveland Hall Jr.’s possible victims.

Detroit Man Charged With Murder Of Missing Cousin Zion Foster

The Michigan teen was reported missing on Jan. 4, 2022, but it took several weeks before the tragic truth came out.

Beloved Detroit Neurosurgeon Found Murdered In His Home

Detroit neurosurgeon Devon Hoover, 53, was discovered fatally shot and wrapped in a blanket in the crawl space of his attic on April 23, 2023. Police are now searching for answers about his murder.

Who Lured Trusting 10-Year-Old Amy Mihaljevic To Her Death In 1989?

The baffling murder mystery continues to haunt friends, family and police to this day.