'Citizen P.I.' Explores The World Of Amateur Sleuths Who Crack Unsolved Cases

This six-episode series showcases the colorful personalities of people who dive headfirst into the rabbit hole to solve violent crimes.

July 14, 2021

Screenshot from Citizen P.I. on discovery+ [via Discovery Inc.]

Screenshot from Citizen P.I. on discovery+ [via Discovery Inc.]

By: Crime Feed Staff

When criminal investigations fail, and justice seems like it’s out of reach – sometimes it only takes one brave citizen to crack the case. Citizen P.I. is a new investigative series that examines the phenomenon of amateur sleuths who have played major roles in cracking real unsolved cases. This six-episode series showcases the colorful personalities of people who dive headfirst into the rabbit hole to solve violent crimes. While some people may view this simply as a hobby, these digital detectives can play a significant role in the apprehension of real criminals. Citizen P.I. will be available to stream on discovery+ beginning Tuesday, July 27.

Each episode of Citizen P.I. follows one or more amateur sleuths as they investigate a case that poses a significant interest to them: a series of dead ends leaves a killer on the loose in the hills of Malibu, California; a victim is found buried deep in the woods of East Texas; and a woman’s controversial death is ruled a suicide, leaving a Florida community divided for more than a decade. When a case goes cold, justice might seem like it’s out of reach. But sometimes, one brave Citizen P.I. can make a difference.

Malibu Sniper

When a young father of two is found shot in in his tent on a camping trip in idyllic Malibu State Creek Park, resident citizen journalist Cece Woods uncovers a string of unreported shootings in the area leading up to the murder. In the months following the shootings, Cece pressures the LA Sheriff’s Department to keep the public informed. When her request is ignored, Cece takes matters into her own hands to inform the public of the sniper who is on the loose in Malibu Canyon.

Sleuths Under Fire

In 2010, in St. Johns County, Florida, Sheriff Deputy Jeremy Banks makes an emotional 911 call. His co-workers respond and arrive at his home where his girlfriend lies dead. Jeremy says it was a suicide, but her family and friends disagree. Years later, an amateur investigator looking into the case winds up dead. Amateur investigators Javier Leiva and John Taylor make it their mission to uncover the truth about both deaths.

Emails From Death Row

In Pensacola, Florida, independent journalist Rick Outzen is drawn into a story that takes over his life. When a local couple is murdered in their home in front of their children, police will do whatever it takes to solve the horrific crime, including asking the media for help. Rick’s investigative tactics coupled with his contacts provide invaluable insight into the killers and the shocking motive behind one of Florida’s most notorious crimes.

The DNA Detectives

In 2006 in Gregg County, Texas, two hunters out for target practice find the body of an unidentified young woman. Her death haunts the detectives of the Gregg County Sheriff’s Department for more than ten years. But when amateur sleuths with the DNA Doe Project take the case in 2018, the race heats up to solve the identity of the victim and bring a killer to justice.

A Failure in the System

In 2010, 29-year-old Hera McLeod set up an online dating profile and soon met someone that she hoped would be the man of her dreams. But shortly after giving birth to their son, a shocking betrayal proves that everything she knew about him was a lie. She soon realizes the terrible truth: she was sleeping next to a dangerous killer. Desperate to protect her son, Hera goes on a mission to prove his true identity and prevent him from killing again.

I Will Find You

In Shreveport, Louisiana, best friends Jeanie Phelps and Patty Thorington investigate the murder of Jeanie’s beloved sister Carol Ann. After decades of searching, Carol Ann’s remains are formally identified. Now the search for her killer begins – a search that has consumed both women for decades.

CITIZEN P.I. is produced for discovery+ by Lion Television. For Lion Television, Allison Corn, Stan Hsue, Stephen McLaughlin, and Jennifer Silverman are Executive Producers. Lorna Thomas is Executive Producer for discovery+.

Next Up

Whitey Bulger: 5 Pop Culture Takes on Boston's Irish Mob Legend

Whitey Bulger was murdered in October 2018 at the high-security penitentiary USP Hazelton in West Virginia at 89 years old. CrimeFeed looks back at the 5 pop culture takes on the notorious Irish gangster.

Video: Samuel Little Is The Most Prolific Serial Killer on Record

How did the most prolific serial killer in U.S. history go undetected for so long?

What We Know About The Atlanta Spa Shootings

All across the United States people have come together to show solidarity for Asian, Asian-American, and Pacific Islander communities after the shootings left eight dead, six of whom were Asian women.

Robert Durst: Murder Trial Set, Old Evidence Allowed, New Insights Revealed

Robert Durst: An ID Murder Mystery goes up close with those who know him best — and fear him most.