‘There Are More Questions Than Answers’: Missing Illinois Grad Student Found Dead

Loved ones of Jelani Day vow they won’t stop until they find out what happened to him.

September 29, 2021
Jelani Day

Jelani Day

Photo by: Bloomington Police Department

Bloomington Police Department

Jelani Day

By: Aaron Rasmussen

A missing graduate student in Illinois was recently found dead in a river, and his loved ones suspect foul play.

“None of this makes sense,” Eriel Davis told Chicago’s WLS-TV of her cousin, 25-year-old Jelani Day.

“His dad actually has cancer and Jelani is the bone marrow match for his dad, and he would never abandon his father like that,” Davis explained. “He would come here in Chicago and visit him at Northwestern hospital, sit with him, you know, encourage him, pray with him.”

Officials said Day’s family hadn’t heard from him since Aug. 23, and he was last seen alive on the campus of Illinois State University in Bloomington, where he was studying speech pathology, the following day. The aspiring doctor’s family reported him missing on Aug. 25.

Day’s car was located in Peru, Illinois, on Aug. 26, but a search of the area turned up nothing, according to police. On Sept. 4, a body was found floating in the nearby Illinois River and DNA testing and dental forensic identification confirmed the remains belonged to Day almost three weeks later.

“I'm very upset because I can't even look at my son's body. His body has deteriorated to the point where I can't say a proper goodbye to him,” Carmen Bolden Day told Good Morning America on Sept. 29.

The LaSalle County coroner has not determined Day’s cause of death, and autopsy and toxicology results are pending.

“At this moment there are more questions than answers surrounding Jelani's disappearance and death, and that is where we will focus our energy,” Day’s family recently wrote in a statement. “As of this moment, we do not know what happened to Jelani and we will not stop until we do.”

“Jelani did not just disappear into thin air,” his mother said on GMA. “Somebody knows something, somebody seen something, and I need somebody to say something.”

The family’s attorney, Hallie Bezner, told the show Day had never been in Peru before and his wallet was found in a different area than where some clothing and his school identification were discovered.

On Aug. 25, one day after he was last seen alive, a security camera captured video of a man knocking on the door of a home near where Day’s body was later found. On Sept. 29, authorities ruled the man out as a person of interest after they "verified the man was in the neighborhood as part of his employment," according to WEEK-TV.

Authorities have not named any suspects in the case.

The victim's family urges anyone who may have been in contact with Jelani Day in the days or weeks before his disappearance and death to contact Bloomington Police Detective Paul Jones at (309) 434-2548, or by email at pjones@cityblm.org.

“Jelani was ambitious. He was driven. He was focused. He was energetic. He was full of life,” Bolden Day said of her son. “Jelani was a person that you couldn't help but love.”

Next Up

In 2006, College Student Jesse Ross Walked Out Of A Hotel & Disappeared

The 19-year-old student reportedly visited Chicago for a Model U.N. event, walked out a back door, and disappeared.

Update: Devin Bond, 16, Reportedly Left Home With A Gun In 2017 & Hasn't Been Seen Since

The hunt continues for the Tennessee teen who allegedly snuck out in the middle of the night and disappeared.

Lost, Bruised Teen Tells Police He’s Timmothy Pitzen, Boy Who Went Missing In 2011

Authorities are waiting for DNA test results; Pitzen's family is “cautiously optimistic.”

Mackenzie Lueck Took A Lyft To Meet Someone In A Park At 3 A.M. — Then Disappeared

The driver has reportedly been cleared; the 23-year-old University of Utah sorority sister has not been seen since June 17.

5 Things To Know About Lori Vallow And The Investigation Into Her Missing Kids

The Idaho mom’s son and daughter disappeared without a trace in September.

Parents Of 23-Year-Old Phoenix Coldon, Who Disappeared 7 Years Ago, Still Searching For Answers

Seven years ago, 23-year-old Phoenix Coldon backed her SUV out of the driveway of her family’s home in Missouri – and vanished.

Tara Calico, Missing Since 1988, Might Have Been Spotted In A Mysterious Polaroid

Tara Calico's last words to her mother were, “Mom, if I'm not back by 12, come look for me."

Elaine Park's Family & Boyfriend Are Mystified At Her Uncharacteristic Disappearance

Police scoured the area for clues and conducted a search using bloodhounds and cadaver dogs — but they found no trace of Elaine Park.

Matthew Weaver Disappeared While Hiking After Sending A Disturbing Snapchat Message

As loved ones search for the 21-year-old California man, they have asked the public to help find him.