Two Missing Boys Last Seen Playing Together Found Dead In Different NYC Rivers

The bodies of missing young boys Alfa Barrie, 11, and Garrett Warren, 13, were discovered in two different Manhattan rivers.

May 24, 2023

New York Police Department

The bodies of two boys who went missing between May 12 and May 13 have been identified. Alfa Barrie, 11, and Garrett Warren, 13, were last seen playing together near a river’s edge in Harlem, yet they were found days apart in two different rivers in Manhattan, reported CNN.

The boys didn’t go to the same school but were thought to be friends. Barrie lived in the Bronx and was a student at Democracy Prep charter school in Harlem. Warren lived in Harlem and was a student at New Explorations into Science, Technology and Math, abbreviated NEST+M, in Lower Manhattan.

According to The New York Times, Alfa Barrie was reported missing on May 14, and his body was recovered from the Hudson River on May 20. His cause of death has not yet been released. Garrett Warren was reported missing on May 15, and his body recovered from the Harlem River on May 18. His cause of death has been determined to be accidental drowning.

Police sources told PIX11 News that 13-year-old Garrett was seen pushing 11-year-old Alfa into the Harlem River, then he slipped and subsequently fell into the water himself. It was an apparent game of roughhousing, claimed another boy who was there and witnessed the tragic incident. He did not call authorities right away but later told an adult who called 911.

The boys had been seen on surveillance footage the evening of May 12 around the area of the Harlem River shoreline where there is a broken fence. The third boy is seen in the video with them. When police received 911 calls that evening, the New York Police Department searched the Harlem River but didn’t find anything despite searching all night.

Although the bodies being found in two different rivers seemed odd to some when it was reported, it’s not unusual for people who enter a body of water at the same spot to end up in very different places. Captain Richard Werner, the owner of Safe Boating America, told The New York Times that “many factors” can determine how far currents carry someone. Those include the strength of a current at a specific time, how well a person can swim, whether a person can hold onto an object while in the water, and in which direction a person is carried.

Werner said, “The currents in any river can be hazardous, but the Hudson and the Harlem rivers are unique because both are large bodies of water with high commercial traffic and fast currents.”

GoFundMe pages were started for the families of both Alfa Barrie and Garrett Warren.

“Alfa was someone who was a huge part of his school community — always lending a helping hand to his classmates and teachers, always showing his care and sweetness to his closest friends and family, and always living life with a smile on his face,” the sixth-grader’s school, Democracy Prep, posted about him. They also recalled how he loved to dance and shared a video of the young boy dancing.

Garrett also left a strong impression within his school community at NEST+M. A staff member told NBC News, “Garrett was a kind, funny and goofy child who loved to make his peers and his friends laugh. He would do silly dances just to get a giggle and help people feel better.”

Iesha Sekou, the chief executive and founder of Street Corner Resources, a Harlem-based anti-violence organization, said that the boys’ deaths showed the dangers of playing in the areas around New York City’s rivers, reported The New York Times. She said that Street Corners Resources reached out to NYC leaders to discuss how important it is for the city’s children to have more safe spaces.

Next Up

In February 2001, Steven Kraft, Jr. Took His Dogs Outside And Disappeared

Over two decades ago, a 12-year-old boy went missing from outside his home in Benton Harbor, Michigan. The two dogs he was playing with have since been found but he remains missing.

The Twists And Turns Of The Infamous Susan Smith Case

On October 25, 1994, the 23-year-old South Carolina mother drowned her two young children.

Have You Seen Missing Teenagers Asia Wilbon Or Mackenzie Marken?

Both girls vanished during the night from their families’ homes.

Woman Pleads Guilty To Fatally Shoving 87-Year-Old Broadway Singing Coach

Lauren Pazienza pleaded guilty to manslaughter and was sentenced to eight years behind bars for the 2022 shoving death of NYC music coach Barbara Maier Gustern.

It's Been More Than 15 Years Since Bianca Piper Vanished At Age 13

The National Center for Missing and Exploited Children has a hotline dedicated to finding missing kids. If you know where Bianca "B" Piper is today, please reach out directly: 1-800-THE-LOST

Oregon Man Arrested For 1974 Cold Case Murders Of Two Teen Boys

In 1974, Steven Paul Criss allegedly shot and killed two teenagers in Washington County, Oregon. Two years later, in 1976, he killed his commanding officer in the army with the same gun.

Police Continue Search For Relisha Rudd, Who Was 8 When She Vanished In 2014

‘I have days when I think she's alive. I have days when I think she's no longer with us,’ says Henderson Long of D.C.’s Missing Voices.

The Alissa Turney Case: What If You Thought Your Dad Killed Your Stepsister?

Over the years, police have declined to arrest Michael Turney or to name him a suspect, but daughter Sarah is convinced that Michael may know more than he has revealed.

5 Things You Need To Know About Susan Powell

In 2009, mother-of-two Susan Powell disappeared without a trace in West Valley City, Utah. Then in 2012, her husband Josh killed himself and their two sons after custody of the children was granted to Susan's parents.

Toddler Who Was Kidnapped By Her Babysitter Reunited With Family Over Five Decades Later

On Aug. 23, 1971, Melissa Highsmith was kidnapped by her babysitter in Fort Worth, Texas. 51 years later, DNA testing helped her family find her.