Who Killed Michelle O’Keefe? Teen Found Dead in Mustang After Kid Rock Video Shoot

A wrongfully convicted man spent 11 years behind bars for the murder, but he was acquitted in 2017.

Michelle O'Keefe, pictured here smiling in her cheerleading uniform, was found shot to death in her car on Feb. 22, 2000.

Michelle O'Keefe, a teenager who spent a day on a video shoot in California, was later discovered dead in her vehicle, and a man falsely accused of fatally shooting her would spend 11 years in prison before a judge acquitted him of her murder.

Photo by: Warner Bros. Discovery, Inc. (Screenshot from "Dateline on ID")

Warner Bros. Discovery, Inc. (Screenshot from "Dateline on ID")

By: Aaron Rasmussen

A teenager who spent a day on a video shoot in California was later discovered dead in her vehicle, and a man falsely accused of fatally shooting her would spend 11 years in prison before a judge acquitted him of her murder.

On Feb. 22, 2000, Michelle O’Keefe, 18, joined her friend Jennifer Peterson at the Shrine Auditorium in Los Angeles for a Kid Rock project. Later that evening, Peterson dropped O’Keefe off at a Palmdale park-and-ride lot where she had left her blue Mustang. Peterson then drove away after she saw O’Keefe get inside the vehicle and switch on the lights, the Los Angeles Times reported.

At around 9:30 p.m. emergency responders discovered O’Keefe unresponsive and partially undressed in the blood-spattered front seat of the Mustang, which was still parked in the lot. An autopsy determined she had been shot multiple times.

Robbery reportedly didn’t appear to be a motive in the case since the victim’s purse and money were still in the car, but there were few other clues to go on.

During the police investigation, detectives learned security guard Ray Jennings was hired to patrol the park-and-ride, and he had called 911 after finding O’Keefe shot in the vehicle. According to the Los Angeles Times, detectives began to zero in on Jennings as the main suspect in the case because he failed to attempt CPR on O’Keefe — he said she was still clinging to life when he discovered her — out of fear he could possibly contaminate the crime scene.

In December 2005, nearly six years after O’Keefe was shot to death, Jennings was charged with her murder. Despite having no physical evidence against Jennings, he was convicted at his third trial (the first two resulted in hung juries) and sentenced to serve up to life in prison for the teenager’s murder.

Jennings had been incarcerated for years when father and son Jeffrey and Clinton Ehrlich reportedly began to look into the case and concluded Jennings likely didn’t commit the homicide. The two contended O’Keefe’s killing was the result of a violent robbery or carjacking attempt, the Los Angeles Times reported.

“There were other people at the scene, and the D.A.’s office was aware of them, but they only looked at Mr. Jennings,” Jeffrey Ehrlich said, according to the publication.

The men told prosecutors in a letter that an eyewitness recalled seeing a man flee the park-and-ride in a Toyota Tercel, and an alleged street gang member was in the area the night of the murder.

Thanks, in part, to the pair’s efforts, Jennings was released from prison in June 2016.

The evidence, in part, seemed to “undermine the entire prosecution case and point unerringly to innocence or reduced culpability,” the judge said at the time, KTLA reported.

Jennings was acquitted of the murder charge in January 2017.

O’Keefe’s murder remains unsolved.

Next Up

Quadruple Homicide In Texas Yogurt Shop Remains Unsolved After Over 30 Years

Who brutally murdered teenagers Eliza Thomas, Jennifer Harbison, Sarah Harbison, and Amy Ayers in 1991?

South Carolina Store Owner Charged With Murder After Shooting Of 14-Year-Old Boy

14-year-old Cyrus Carmack-Belton was allegedly chased, shot, and killed by the owner of a convenience store on May 28, 2023. Rick Chow, 58, has since been charged with his murder.

Can You Help Solve Any Of These Massachusetts Murder Cases?

Authorities and loved ones continue to hold out hope that the killers will someday be brought to justice.

Georgia Police Officer Arrested In Connection With 16-Year-Old Girl’s Death

After the remains of a missing 16-year-old girl were found in the woods of an Atlanta suburb on Feb. 6, a local police officer was arrested in connection with the crime.

Man Sentenced For Killing Teen After She Visited His Garage Sale

In August 2019, Arthur Jensen lured 17-year-old Adara Bunn back to his home after meeting her at his garage sale and promising her Disney merchandise for her collection. When she arrived back at his home, he murdered her.

String Of Mysterious Disappearances, Deaths Has Small Texas County On Edge

“It seems odd that they all know each other and suddenly have fallen victim to foul play,” a private investigator says.

Teens Arrested In Shooting Death Of Tennessee High School Class President

17-year-old Christine Michael had recently left a basketball game when someone began shooting at the car in which she was riding on Feb. 10.

Suspect Charged With The Delphi Murders Of Two Teen Girls

In February 2017, Liberty German and Abigail Williams were killed while on a hike in Delphi, Indiana. In October 2022, a man was charged with their murders.

Unsolved Mystery: Pennsylvania Woman Shot Dead While Shoveling Snow In Her Driveway

Louisa Krenzel was hit by multiple bullets fired from a distance, investigators determined.

What Happened To Stephen Smith? The Murdaugh Family Mystery Continues

Buster Murdaugh, the son of disgraced attorney Alex Murdaugh, has denied having anything to do with the July 2015 death of 19-year-old Stephen Smith, which has now officially been ruled a homicide.