Woman Convicted Of Murdering Boyfriend She Met Through Online Alien Cult

‘I was not in control of the situation that happened,’ Barbara Rogers claimed of Steven Mineo’s 2017 shooting death.

August 05, 2021
woman's mugshot on the left picture of her ex boyfriend on the right

Barbara Rogers (left) and her ex-boyfriend Steven Mineo (right) [screenshots via WNEP]

Barbara Rogers (left) and her ex-boyfriend Steven Mineo (right) [screenshots via WNEP]

By: Aaron Rasmussen

A woman who first met her boyfriend through their involvement with a cult that believed in fallen angels who took the form of aliens and UFOs said he forced her to kill him.

In 2016, Steven Mineo, 32, and Barbara Rogers, two members of Ohio-based Sherry Shriner’s online cult, began communicating with each other and decided to meet in person.

After Mineo and Rogers rented a home together in Pocono, Pennsylvania, they quickly grew serious.

For more on this story, stream the "Evil Spirits" episode on Season 14 of Deadly Women with Candice DeLong.

Cult leader Shriner, who only communicated with devotees online or by phone, didn’t like the development and she grew wary of Rogers' blossoming relationship with the inexperienced Mineo.

As the months passed, Rogers’ behavior became increasingly erratic. She wasn’t taking her medication for a bipolar disorder she was diagnosed with while serving in the military, and she allegedly grew delusional and struggled with impulse control as she drank more and more.

Mineo’s online mentor and mother figure, Shriner, later said in an interview that she believed Rogers may have had a demon or lizard manifested in her and warned that “a human’s no match for that kind of supernatural strength.” She reportedly warned Mineo to be careful.

In the early morning hours of July 15, 2017, Mineo and Rogers were drinking and shooting his .45-caliber handgun at their Coolbaugh Township home. After they returned inside, Robins’ defense attorneys said at trial, Mineo forced his girlfriend to shoot him, according to WNEP.

“My boyfriend had a gun. He told me to hold it here and press the trigger. Oh my God, he's dead!” Rogers, who later claimed she didn’t know the firearm was still loaded, told a 911 dispatcher.

Mineo suffered a fatal gunshot wound to the head.

Rogers allegedly told officers her boyfriend was upset at the time of his death because he had come to believe cult leader Shriner was a “reptilian” — or extraterrestrial — posing as a human, the Pocono Record reported. As a result, Robins said, he forced her to aim the gun point-blank at the middle of his forehead and pull the trigger.

In March 2019, a Monroe County jury convicted Rogers of third-degree murder, and a judge sentenced her to 15 to 40 years behind bars.

Under Pennsylvania law, a third-degree murder conviction requires proof of malice — knowledge that the conduct in question could pose a threat to human life — but not intent to kill.

“I was not in control of the situation that happened. I was not the dominating party in that situation," Rogers told reporters after her sentencing, according to WNEP.

The prosecutor and Mineo’s family said the now-44-year-old convicted killer should have been found guilty of first-degree murder and they criticized the punishment as too lenient.

Shriner always denied she was the leader of a cult. She passed away in 2018.

Next Up

‘I Was Sitting There Defending A Guilty Person’: Woman Receives Devastating Package From Incarcerated Partner

“I thought, I’ve got to fix this, I’ve got to make it right. They’ve got the wrong person.”

Loved Ones Of Ex-Marine Convicted Of Murder Fight To Clear His Name

The family of an Iraq war veteran is asking retired detective Chris Anderson and criminal defense attorney Fatima Silva of Reasonable Doubt to re-examine Tim Wright Jr.’s 2008 murder conviction.

UPDATE: U.S. Marshals Nab "In Pursuit with John Walsh" Convicted Killer In Alabama

The U.S. Marshals closed in on Maurice Nesbitt in Birmingham, Alabama. The arrest makes the 25th fugitive featured and captured from "In Pursuit with John Walsh."

5 Essential Things To Know About The Horrific Jodi Arias Case

Jodi Arias was sentenced to life in prison without parole, but does she have a chance for a new trial?

Body Of Shannon Graves Found In Freezer, Suspect's New Girlfriend Moved In and Stole Her Identity

Katrina Layton began using Shannon Graves' credit card and cell phone, driving her car, and taking care of her dog.

5 Essential Facts You Need To Know About The Adnan Syed Case

From the Serial podcast to a new HBO documentary, Adnan Syed's role in the murder of Hae Min Lee continues to captivate with one question: “Is he guilty or innocent?”

5 Eye-Opening Facts About Life Behind Bars For Jodi Arias

From prison tattoos to Ding Dongs to her lawyer blaming her for his cancer, here's what lockup is like for the notorious “Boyfriend Killer.”

In 2013, Kelsie Schelling Sent An Ultrasound Image To Her Boyfriend — Then Disappeared

Donthe Lucas is awaiting trial for his ex-girlfriend's alleged murder but, after six long years of searching, her body has never been found.

Florida Woman Claims Boyfriend Died In Zipped Suitcase While Playing Hide-And-Seek

Sarah Boone has been charged with second-degree murder in the death of Jorge Torres Jr.