Woman Accused of Slitting Boyfriend's Throat After Claiming He Fell Off a Cliff

September 18, 2017
By: Catherine Townsend

Garrett County Sheriff’s Office

Garrett County Sheriff’s Office

FROSTBURG, MD — A Maryland woman who claimed that her boyfriend plunged to his death from a cliff has been accused of slitting his throat and killing him.

Megan Virginia Shaffer, 21, has been charged with second-degree murder, manslaughter, and assisting another to commit or attempt to commit suicide, according to The Cumberland Times-News.

In transcripts from a 911 call to Garret County emergency services obtained by The Associated Press, Shaffer claimed that she and her boyfriend, 24-year-old Alexander Stevens, had been hiking in Savage River State Forest on January 3.

She told police that Stevens fell off a 33-foot overlook — and she then wandered around lost in the woods until the next morning, when she called 911 from a nearby home. Shaffer was taken to a hospital, where she was treated for a broken shoulder and potentially broken back.

Stevens’ naked body was found the next day and, according to the newspaper, his throat had been cut several times. There were burned-down candles near his corpse, and Stevens’ cat in a cage.

Following a request by Stevens’ father, a judge agreed to stop the transfer of funds from a “transfer on death” account of his, opened just days before the incident, that listed Shaffer as the beneficiary. The transfer would have awarded $188,000 to Shaffer.

Shaffer was being held at the Garrett County Detention Center, but has been released after posting bond.

Jay Stevens, Alexander’s father, explained how his son’s expulsion from the Coast Guard in his senior year devastated him. Apparently, the students change rooms every September. Alexander, after drinking, accidentally entered the room of a girl who was staying in the room that had previously been his girlfriend’s. He had reached under her blanket and touched her before realizing his mistake. He reported the incident, due to the honor code, and was “disenrolled” from the academy as punishment.

Despite how upset Alexander was over this, and some ways he’d changed since then, Jay is sure that his son never would have wanted to end his life.

“He’d grown his hair longer … was reading about religions, thinking about his place in society,” Jay Stevens said.

“I never, never, ever, ever thought that he was suicidal … I know my son … He had all these plans to do things … had purchased all these toys for the cat.”

The following video shows Alexander Stevens singing with the United States Coast Guard Academy Glee Club in 2012.

Next Up

300-Pound Woman Pleads Guilty To Fatally Smothering Her Boyfriend By Sitting On Him

Investigators say Windi Thomas attacked her boyfriend with a knife and beat him with a table leg before smothering him with her body.

5 Essential Facts You Need To Know About The Adnan Syed Case

From the Serial podcast to a new HBO documentary, Adnan Syed's role in the murder of Hae Min Lee continues to captivate with one question: “Is he guilty or innocent?”

Good Samaritan Stopped To Help A Woman & Her Baby & Is Fatally Stabbed

When Jacquelyn Smith rolled down the passenger seat window to give the woman money, police say a man approached the car.

Prosecutors Say Adnan Syed's DNA Was NOT Found On Tested Items From Crime Scene

“There is no forensic evidence linking him to this crime,” defense attorney C. Justin Brown tweeted.

Adnan Syed Of 'Serial' Fame Denied New Trial, Maryland Court Upholds Conviction

Adnan Syed continues to serve life for the 1999 murder of his high school ex-girlfriend Hae Min Lee.

5 Eye-Opening Facts About Life Behind Bars For Jodi Arias

From prison tattoos to Ding Dongs to her lawyer blaming her for his cancer, here's what lockup is like for the notorious “Boyfriend Killer.”

In 2013, Kelsie Schelling Sent An Ultrasound Image To Her Boyfriend — Then Disappeared

Donthe Lucas is awaiting trial for his ex-girlfriend's alleged murder but, after six long years of searching, her body has never been found.

5 Essential Things To Know About The Sensational Jodi Arias Case

Inside the rise to infamy of the notorious “Boyfriend Killer.”