Wisconsin Babysitter Allegedly Tricked Mom Into Believing Her Dead Newborn Was Asleep

The woman bundled the infant up in a snowsuit and pulled a hat down over his eyes.

January 07, 2019
Marissa Tietsort [Marathon County Sheriff’s Office]

Marissa Tietsort [Marathon County Sheriff’s Office]

Marissa Tietsort [Marathon County Sheriff’s Office]

By: Aaron Rasmussen

WAUSAU, WI — Police claim a Wisconsin babysitter killed a two-month old infant before bundling him up in winter gear and then returning him to his mother.

On January 4, authorities charged Marissa Tietsort, 28, with first-degree intentional homicide for the alleged October 18 incident.

According to a criminal complaint, Tietsort was aware the newborn in her care was dead, but instead of calling for help, she concocted a ruse to make it appear he was just asleep.

The complaint alleged: “Tietsort admitted that she put the [baby’s] lifeless body on the floor in the hallway of her home, dressed him in the snowsuit, and then placed his body in the car seat with his blankets.” She did not “check for a pulse, she did not reach out for help, and she did not perform any resuscitation efforts.”

Tietsort then took the deceased infant and his older brother, who she was also watching, on a trip to McDonalds for dinner after her boyfriend had returned from work.

At the end of her babysitting shift, she handed over the dead newborn, still in the car seat, to his mother when she came to pick him up around 9 P.M. She “thought [the baby] was sleeping, as he would normally be sleeping at that time of the day,” an investigator wrote, adding Tietsort “purposefully put a hat over the [baby’s] eyes so that the … mother would not realize her son was dead.”

The mom brought the child to Northway Coin Laundry, where she finally noticed he was cold, rigid, and not breathing. She called 911 and attempted CPR. Officers responding to the scene observed the child "had an ashen skin tone, his jaw was clenched, and his lips were blue,” read the complaint.

Detectives searching for Tietsort finally located her swimming with her boyfriend and young son at the Plaza Hotel just after 4 A.M. the following morning.

The Wausau Daily Herald reported that an autopsy showed the infant had died from blunt-force trauma with multiple impacts to the head. Forensic pathologist Robert Corliss also noted the baby’s tailbone was "fractured, broken off, and displaced, indicating a significant amount of force was used."

Tietsort, who is being held at the Marathon County Jail in lieu of a $500,000 cash bond, is now also under arrest for a second child-abuse charge stemming from an August incident in which she is accused of injuring an 11-month-old girl she was babysitting. In that case, she claimed the child fell off a couch, resulting in facial injuries.

Records show that Tietsort, who is currently pregnant for the sixth time, had four of her children removed from her care following allegations of abuse in 2010. The courts were reportedly unaware she had given birth to a fifth child.

Tietsort is due to appear in court on January 18.

Next Up

True Crime News Roundup: Texas Mom Allegedly Strangled Her 5-Year-Old Daughter While She Pleaded For Her Life

Plus: Paul Flores found guilty of murdering Kristin Smart; Princeton student found dead; Man confesses to spring break murder of Brittanee Drexel; Mississippi daycare workers arrested for child abuse.

Colorado Dentist Allegedly Kills Wife By Poisoning Her Protein Shakes

James Toliver Craig had allegedly tried to poison his wife another time five years before her death.

Toddler Who Was Kidnapped By Her Babysitter Reunited With Family Over Five Decades Later

On Aug. 23, 1971, Melissa Highsmith was kidnapped by her babysitter in Fort Worth, Texas. 51 years later, DNA testing helped her family find her.

Natasha 'Alex' Carter Missing Since 2000, Allegedly Abducted By Her Mother

The National Center for Missing and Exploited Children created an age enhanced photo of what Natasha “Alex” Carter may look like at 29-years-old. She has a scar on her left eyebrow.

A Texas Child Is Missing After Her Father Allegedly ‘Gave’ Her To Someone At A Convenience Store

Tiara McWilliams had tried in vain to get her daughter, Ameera Deadrick, back from her father for years after a summer trip turned into a permanent arrangement.

Missing Connecticut Mom Jennifer Dulos Officially Declared Dead As Trial Begins

Jennifer Dulos, a missing mother of five from New Canaan, Connecticut, was officially declared dead, and now her ex’s girlfriend, Michelle Troconis, is on trial in connection with her murder.

Florida Teen Left Paralyzed After Ex-Boyfriend Allegedly Stabs Her Outside Restaurant

A high school softball star who was allegedly being stalked by her ex-boyfriend is left without feeling in her legs after being stabbed over a dozen times.

Missouri Pair Allegedly Kidnapped Woman, Held Her Captive In Cage, Authorities Say

An anonymous tipster reportedly sent the FBI a photo of the victim restrained and partially nude.

A Young Wisconsin Woman Was Killed Leaving Work, Her Case Went Unsolved For 10 Years

The lead detective on the 1999 murder case assured Theresa Wesolowski’s family he would not retire until he found her killer.

Woman Found Dead After Hosting Halloween Costume Party At Her Apartment

Whoever killed Arpana Jinaga doused her with motor oil and scrubbed her fingernails with toilet bowl cleaner.