Vanilla Coke Can Helps Crack 40-Year-Old Colorado Cold Case

David Dwayne Anderson is accused of sexually assaulting, strangling, stabbing and shooting Sylvia Quayle in 1981.

April 09, 2021
David Dwayne Anderson (left) and Sylvia Quayle (right) [via the Cherry Hills Village, Colorado Police Department]

David Dwayne Anderson (left) and Sylvia Quayle (right) [via the Cherry Hills Village, Colorado Police Department]

David Dwayne Anderson (left) and Sylvia Quayle (right) [via the Cherry Hills Village, Colorado Police Department]

By: Aaron Rasmussen

DNA collected from a Vanilla Coke can recently led to the arrest of a suspect accused of brutally attacking and murdering a woman in Colorado nearly four decades ago, police said.

On August 4, 1981, Sylvia Quayle’s nude body was discovered in her Cherry Hills Village home. Police said the 35-year-old victim had been sexually assaulted, strangled, stabbed in the heart and lungs, and shot in the head. She died from massive blood loss.

Investigators recovered 140 pieces of evidence from the scene and in 1995 sent a rug, which years before had been determined to contain foreign material, to the Colorado Bureau of Investigation for DNA testing.

Five years later, in 2000, experts developed an unknown male DNA profile, but it wasn’t until investigators began working with a genetic research company United Data Connect that they had any luck moving the case forward.

The company took the sequenced DNA data gathered from the crime scene evidence and uploaded it to open-source websites Family Tree DNA and GEDmatch.

“We started to then get connected people that were related to the individual that we were looking for,” said the company’s co-founder, Mitch Morrissey, according to Denver’s KCNC-TV.

Morrisey explained researchers then had to narrow results from a massive extended family tree of connections totaling over 3,300 people down to just one.

At the beginning of 2021, investigators were able to identify the suspect they had been waiting almost 40 years to name: David Dwayne Anderson.

Detectives headed to 62-year-old Anderson’s home in Cozad, Nebraska, and surreptitiously plucked two bags of trash Anderson had thrown out. Inside one was a Vanilla Coke can. It would be the key that cracked the cold case.

On January 29, DNA test results indicated genetic material from the can matched that on the rug from the murder scene, and police arrested Anderson 13 days later.

Anderson was expected to be extradited to Colorado, where he faces a charge of first-degree murder and sexual assault. If convicted, he could be sentenced to life in prison without parole based on laws in place at the time of Quayle’s slaying.

“I am proud to be able to tell Sylvia’s sister and brother-in-law that the men and women of our department have anticipated the opportunity to make this announcement for almost forty years,” Cherry Hills Village Police Chief Michelle Tovrea said after Anderson’s arrest, according to The Denver Post.

Tovrea noted that after so much time had passed there is now “a path moving forward to seek justice in her death.”

Next Up

‘Justice Has Been Done’: Genetic Genealogy Solves Soldier's 1987 Murder

A Colorado jury has found former Fort Carson soldier Michael Whyte guilty of strangling fellow servicemember Darlene Krashoc to death.

CAUGHT ON TAPE: LAPD Needs Your Help To Find Suspect Wanted For Violent Attack

The alleged attack was caught on video by a local business in Los Angeles, CA. At the time of the attack police said the victim was inside the store and was challenged to a fight. The altercation took place right outside the store.

Aspiring Drug Kingpin Fatally Shot Newlyweds, Plotted Murder-For-Hire Scheme

James Charles Tooley was connected to the 2008 double homicide after his cousin turned him in.

Man Freed After Spending 21 Years In Prison For Murder Despite Another Man’s Confession

McKinley ‘Mac’ Phipps said he had stopped believing in people and the system: ‘Everything was just dark.’

America Remembers George Floyd: A Movement

George Floyd aka “Big Floyd” is remembered by loved ones as a “gentle giant.”

What To Know About The Police Killing Of Rayshard Brooks

In June 2020, the 34-year-old Black man was shot and killed by an Atlantic Police officer in a Wendy’s parking lot.

Four Oklahoma Men Left For A Bicycle Ride, Their Dismembered Bodies Were Found A Week Later

A group of Oklahoma men were reported missing after going on a bicycle ride together on Oct. 9, 2022. Less than a week later, their dismembered bodies were pulled from a river.

Genetic Genealogy Solves Murder Of Two Colorado Women After Four Decades

“I never thought I’d see the day, frankly,” says one investigator who worked on the 1982 cold case.

Virginia Woman At Large After Allegedly Fatally Stabbing Her Mom

Alana Renee Cole, 45, remains at large; authorities say she should be considered dangerous.

True Crime News Roundup: Arrest Made In Fatal Shooting Of A Military Mother Visiting Her Son’s Grave

Plus: Woman accused of using kiss to pass drugs to inmate boyfriend who overdosed; authorities limit search for California teen who went missing after graduation party; Salman Rushdie attacker pleads not guilty; and ex-cop in Kansas suspected of 10-year sex-assault spree, police say.