Steven Avery's Lawyer Says It's 'Fairly Obvious' Who Killed Teresa Halbach

Regardless of where you stand on Steven Avery's guilt or innocence, a tainted crime scene, suspicious evidence, and police misconduct serves to harm both the defense and the prosecution's cases.

February 23, 2016
Steven Avery in custody [Investigation Discovery]

Steven Avery in custody [Investigation Discovery]

Steven Avery in custody [Investigation Discovery]

By: Amelia McDonell-Parry

Related To:

Steven Avery's new lawyer, Kathleen Zellner, has been going HAM on social, posting all sorts of vaguely teasing tweets about developments in the case. For starters, as part of her effort to see Avery exonerated for the 2005 murder of Teresa Halbach, Zellner plans to do “advanced luminol testing," and recently paid her client a visit in order to collect fresh DNA samples to test. The attorney, who has successfully represented a number of exonerated prisoners, appears extremely confident that proving Avery innocent is only a matter of time, tweeting, "The inevitable is coming — he was smiling so were we."

Zellner has been rightfully critical of the original police investigation, which was documented on the hit Netflix docu-series, Making A Murderer. Ultimately, regardless of where you stand on Avery's guilt or innocence, a tainted crime scene, suspicious evidence, and police misconduct serves to harm both the defense and the prosecution's cases. In a series of tweets, Zellner raised some really good points about how specific elements of the forensic evidence found on the Avery property — Halbach's car key, her RAV-4, her burned remains, etc. — actually contradict each other.

That special RAV4 key only absorbs DNA of Plaintiff in civil rights suit against MC not owner's. Magic #MakingAMurderer

— Kathleen Zellner (@ZellnerLaw) February 4, 2016

TH throat cut (- blood) Head shot (- spatter) But RAV4 has her blood -so she was put in car & driven 20 ft to burn pit? #MakingAMurderer

— Kathleen Zellner (@ZellnerLaw) February 17, 2016

Killer would not reduce body to bone fragments to destroy evidence but leave car intact w/his blood. #MakingAMurderer

— Kathleen Zellner (@ZellnerLaw) February 19, 2016

She also pointed out that when the search party found Halbach's RAV-4 in the Avery salvage yard, the car was locked. A strange move for a killer to make, considering this only helps "preserve" the evidence, leading Zellner to hint that it was "kinda obvious" who locked it.

Zellner tweeted that Avery's case is "identical to the other 17 men we've cleared" and that she "won't quit until he's out." In her interview with The Lip TV, Zellner emphasized that her confidence in his innocence is based on the very evidence used to convict him.

"In having had a number of these cases, it has the signature of a wrongful conviction case," Zellner said. "They only focused on him. They did not look at a lot of other suspects, certainly some very key people they should have been looking at."

In fact, Zellner and Avery seem to have an exact suspect in mind, not that they're telling, though Zellner says she intends to prove who the real killer is. On February 8, she tweeted a handwritten note from Avery in which he maintains that no one in his family is responsible for Halbach's death, but it's "obvious" who is, and that the police decided chose not to investigate "him."

Police reports: Only SA suspect but BIG RED FLAGS on others. Must have to do w/BIG GREEN DOLLARS. #MakingAMurderer

— Kathleen Zellner (@ZellnerLaw) February 8, 2016

Let's just assume for a moment that Zellner is right and Avery and the rest of his kin are completely innocent in the murder. Based on her tweets and interview quotes, it seems obvious that Zellner is among the many who believe that the cops definitely framed Avery by planting 1) Halbach's key, after giving it a good scrub and B) Avery's blood in the RAV-4 and his DNA on the hood latch. She also may be hinting that the cops planted Halbach's car as well — if they were framing Avery, they would want to make sure nothing happened to the forensic evidence inside by locking the vehicle.

If that's the case, that would mean the police found the RAV-4 somewhere off the Avery property, a theory that was touched on at trial. Remember, on November 3, the day Halbach was reported missing, Officer Andrew Colburn called dispatch with a license plate number for them to run, and they confirmed that it was registered to Halbach. "A '99 Toyota?" he asked, volunteering information that further indicated he was looking at the vehicle in question. Two full days later, the car was officially "found" on the Avery lot.

But the question remains: Who do Zellner and Avery think killed her? It's pretty indisputable that the police had tunnel vision from the moment they learned Halbach had been on the Avery lot, as evidenced by the fact that they ONLY took forensic evidence from the Avery family. But in thinking about the other possible suspects, I'm left wondering if Avery counts his brother-in-law, Scott Tadych — who some consider to be an alternative suspect – as a member of his family? Because Tadych was never fingerprinted, and his trailer — located near Avery's — was never searched.

That said, Zellner has hinted that Halbach was killed by someone she knew.

"There was a very poor investigation done of the victim’s background, who she was involved with, the circumstances of her life," Zellner cryptically told The Lip TV. Perhaps she's thinking of Halbach's ex-boyfriend Ryan Hillegas? Or her roommate, Scott Bloedorn, who waited three days before reporting her missing? It's also possible that she has in mind someone we've yet to hear about because they were never investigated.

I guess we'll have to wait to see what Zellner tweets next...

Read more: Independent UK, Buzzfeed

Next Up

UPDATE: 5 Interesting Facts About The Scott Peterson Case

California governor Gavin Newsom has imposed a moratorium on the death penalty, which could mean that Death Row inmates — including Scott Peterson — are no longer facing certain death.

Former Nurse Arrested In 1999 Cold Case Slaying Of Illinois Woman

The victim suffered "barbaric brutality," according to investigators.

This Real Female Killer Was An Inspiration For Psychopathic 'Killing Eve' Assassin

Investigators say that Angela Simpson stabbed Terry Neely approximately 50 times, dismembered him, and burned his remains in a trash can.

UPDATE: Fugitive Leticia Smith from ‘In Pursuit With John Walsh’ Captured In Mexico

Authorities confirm former fugitive, Leticia Smith was extradited from Mexico to California. Smith will face charges for allegedly killing her husband, Antione Smith.

'Monster' Pamela Hupp Receives Life Sentence For Murder Of Man With Disability

Authorities say Hupp may have killed the victim to set up a frame-job for a second murder in which she is a possible suspect.

David Sparks Charged In Slaying Of Savannah Spurlock, Mother Of 4

David Sparks was arrested in July after the discovery of human remains at a rural Garrard County home allegedly owned by members of Sparks' family.