Nearly 50 Years After Her Death, A Murdered Teen Is Linked To A Serial Killer Cop

A Florida family finally has closure after authorities identified a body recovered in 1974 as 15-year-old Susan Poole.

June 09, 2022
Susan Poole [main] went missing in 1972 and her murder is now being linked to serial killer cop Gerard Schaefer [inset].

Nearly 50 years after Susan Poole's death, her murder is being linked to serial killer cop Gerard Schaefer.

Photo by: Palm Beach County Sheriff's Office [main]; Martin County Sheriff's Office [inset]

Palm Beach County Sheriff's Office [main]; Martin County Sheriff's Office [inset]

Nearly 50 years after the skeleton of a teenage girl was found tied to a mangrove tree, authorities finally know who she is and who killed her.

Genetic genealogy testing that began in 2021 identified the body as Susan Poole, a 15-year-old who was reported missing just before Christmas in 1972 when she went missing from a Broward County, Florida trailer park.

A skeleton, now known to be Poole, was found in 1974 in Palm Beach County off Highway A1A, a scenic route along Florida’s Atlantic coast.

According to reports, her remains were bound to a mangrove tree with a wire. Due to limited forensic technology, authorities had no way to identify her body, and the case grew cold.

The Suspected Serial Killer

At the time of Poole’s disappearance, a yet-unknown serial killer was terrorizing the area. Gerard Schaefer worked as a police officer for a small department, but his short tenure as an officer came to a screeching halt when he kidnapped two hitchhiking teen girls in July 1972. He tied the girls to trees along Highway A1A and said he would be back later, but the pair managed to escape.

Schaefer immediately lost his job and was arrested for kidnapping. While he was on bond and awaiting trial, he reportedly kidnapped and then killed two different teen girls. The teens’ disfigured bodies were discovered in April 1973. As authorities investigated that case, they searched Schaefer’s home and found evidence that linked him to other murders in the area. Schaefer was found guilty of murdering the teens discovered in 1973 and was sentenced to life in prison. According to Murderpedia, he was killed by another inmate in the mid 90s over a dispute about a cup of hot water.

Connecting The Dots

According to CBS News, Palm Beach detective William Springer noted the similarities between Poole’s case and other murder scenes attributed to Schaefer. The detective believes it is very likely she met her end at the hands of Schaefer because she fit his profile and was found in the same fashion as his other victims.

According to WPBF, Springer doesn’t have the physical evidence to say for certain that Shaefer killed Poole, but he believes she was likely hitchhiking and got into his car.

Springer wants to speak with three of Poole’s friends from the time of her disappearance. He believes those friends may be able to answer some questions that could bring answers to Poole’s mother, who is now in her 90s.

Anyone with information on Poole’s activities or her possible connection to Schaefer can reach out to Springer at 561-688-4013. Callers can also remain anonymous by calling Crime Stoppers at 1-800-458-TIPS.

Next Up

DNA From Coffee Cup Solves 1975 Cold Case Murder Of 19-Year-Old Lindy Sue Biechler

In July 2022, one of Lancaster County, Pennsylvania’s oldest cold cases was solved when David Sinopoli, 68, was arrested for the brutal murder of Lindy Sue Biechler.

50 Years Later, Suspect Arrested In Hawaii Murder Of Teenage Girl

On Jan. 7, 1972, Nancy Anderson’s body was found stabbed 63 times in the bedroom of her Honolulu apartment. Her case went unsolved for over 50 years.

Man Sentenced For Killing Teen After She Visited His Garage Sale

In August 2019, Arthur Jensen lured 17-year-old Adara Bunn back to his home after meeting her at his garage sale and promising her Disney merchandise for her collection. When she arrived back at his home, he murdered her.

Suspect Charged With The Delphi Murders Of Two Teen Girls

In February 2017, Liberty German and Abigail Williams were killed while on a hike in Delphi, Indiana. In October 2022, a man was charged with their murders.

Suspect Arrested In 1998 Chat Line Murder Of Teenager

On Nov. 28, 2022, over 20 years after 19-year-old Jennifer Brinkman was found killed by an ax in her Washington bedroom, a man was arrested for her murder.

Cold Case Murder Of Kentucky Teenager Solved Almost 5 Decades Later

16-year-old Carol Sue Klaber was found in a roadside ditch on June 5, 1976. Her murder went unsolved until March 2023 when authorities announced they used genetic genealogy to finally identify her killer.

Texas Killing Fields: Who Murdered Dozens Of Young Girls And Women Near Houston?

The remains of at least 30 victims have been found in a remote area since the early ‘70s.

DNA Helps Solve The 1984 Cold Case Murder Of Donna Macho

New Jersey teen Donna Macho was brutally attacked and murdered in 1984, and after nearly three decades, her killer was positively identified.

Colorado Man Allegedly Kills Teen Coworker In Break Room After She Rejected His Advances

Riley Whitelaw, 17, had previously expressed concerns about her 28-year-old coworker Joshua Johnson, whom she said made her feel uncomfortable.

Fugitive Suspected Of Killing Florida Woman In 1984 Used 13 Aliases While On Run, Police Say

Donald Santini was captured in California and arrested in connection with the strangulation death of Cynthia Ruth Wood.