Man Who Spent Nearly 20 Years In Prison For Murder Released After His Identical Twin Confesses

“I have to get it off my chest before it kills me,” Karl Smith wrote in a letter to his incarcerated brother, Kevin Dugar.

February 04, 2022
(L-R) Kevin Dugar and Karl Smith mugshots

(L-R) Kevin Dugar and Karl Smith

Photo by: Illinois Department of Corrections

Illinois Department of Corrections

(L-R) Kevin Dugar and Karl Smith

By: Aaron Rasmussen

An Illinois man who spent almost two decades behind bars in connection to a fatal shooting in 2003 was released because his identical twin brother confessed to committing the crime.

On the evening of Jan. 25, Kevin Dugar, who was serving a 54-year sentence for first-degree murder, was freed from the Cook County Jail in Chicago, television station WLS reported.

Karl Smith first admitted in 2013 that he — not his brother, Dugar — fired the shots that killed a rival gang member and wounded another man in Chicago 10 years earlier.

“I have to get it off my chest before it kills me,” Smith wrote in a letter to his incarcerated twin. “So I’ll just come clean and pray you can forgive me.”

In 2016, he again claimed responsibility for the murder, this time in court. “I'm here to confess to a crime I committed that he was wrongly accused of,” Smith testified, according to the Chicago Tribune.

A judge ruled the confession was “completely uncredible” since Smith was already in prison serving a 99-year sentence for a 2008 home invasion that ended with a 6-year-old boy shot in the head.

A lawyer with Northwestern Pritzker School of Law’s Northwest Center of Wrongful Convictions took up 44-year-old Dugar’s case, paving the way for the Court of Appeals to review the evidence and agree that Dugar should be released on bond.

“This case is in a very different situation than it was 20 years ago,” said Dugar’s attorney, Ron Safer. “Everybody knows much more about it.”

Dugar could still be tried for the fatal shooting if the Cook County State's Attorney's Office decides to pursue a new trial.

“We are hopeful that the state’s attorney will drop the case against Kevin and then do what they will, but drop the case against Kevin because he’s innocent,” Safer said, adding, “It’s clear that he’s innocent, but if they persist, we will go to trial and we will vindicate him at trial.”

Next Up

How Elusive Serial Killer Ted Kaczynski Was Unmasked As The Unabomber

The self-professed anarchist was captured in 1996 hiding out in a primitive Montana cabin.

80-Year-Old Woman Charged In 1985 Cold Case Murder Of Romantic Rival

A love-triangle resulted in the tragic murder of Yvonne Menke nearly four decades ago. The alleged killer, now 80, has finally been arrested for shooting her three times in her head and neck.

Idaho Attorney Murdered By Mistress’ Husband In Walgreen’s Parking Lot

Ashlee Harmon’s fifth child was just six weeks old when her husband and college sweetheart was gunned down in the parking lot of a pharmacy in 2011.

More Than Half A Century After His Assassination, Dr. King’s Legacy Lives On

On April 4, 1968, James Earl Ray shot and killed the civil rights leader while he stood on the balcony of his Memphis motel room.

Trucker Charged In Kansas City Cold Case Murders, Police Believe There May Be More Victims

A 52-year-old man has been charged with two gruesome cold case murders that have haunted Kansas City for decades.

Can You Help Identify ‘Baby Jane Doe’ Who Was Found In Georgia In December 1988?

The Georgia Bureau of Investigation is offering a reward. According to published reports, investigators believe the child was dead at least two to three months before she was found. If you know anything about this case, please consider calling 800-597-8477.

Vanilla Coke Can Helps Crack 40-Year-Old Colorado Cold Case

In June 2022, David Dwayne Anderson was sentenced to life in prison for the brutal 1981 murder of 34-year-old Sylvia Quayle.

How The Abduction And Murder Of A 9-Year-Old Led To The AMBER Alert System

The AMBER alert system first debuted in 1996 as a collaboration between news media and police in Arlington, Texas. Named for Amber Hagerman, the alerts have helped find more than 1,000 abducted children.

Headless, Handless Body Found In 1980 Was Finally Identified Over Four Decades Later

On March 20, 1980, police in Fishkill, New York found a decapitated and handless body. 42 years later, the body was identified as 44-year-old Manhattan woman Anna L. Papalardo-Blake.

Court Vacates Murder Conviction Of Man Accused Of Killing Oregon Prison Director In 1989

“The facts on appeal are extraordinary,” federal judges said of claims Frank Gable killed Michael Francke during a botched burglary.