Justice Finally Served For Washington Teen Who Was Brutally Murdered In 1991

Over three decades after Sarah Yarborough was brutally murdered on her way to meet her high school drill team, her murderer was finally convicted.

King County Sheriff's Office

On Dec. 14, 1991, 16-year-old honors student Sarah Yarborough drove herself to Federal High School to attend a drill team event. She never made it to the event, and her body was found by two boys in the woods outside the high school later that day.

The Seattle Times reported that, approximately an hour before she was murdered, Yarborough had rushed out of her home in her drill team uniform with her hair in a ponytail. She was found later that day wearing only her skirt and sweater. Her nylons had been wrapped around her neck and apparently used as the murder weapon. She had been strangled to death.

Although investigators worked hard to solve Sarah’s murder, the case eventually went cold before DNA technology helped detectives solve it, reported PEOPLE. Police investigators had gone through countless tips and had considered other suspects before DNA from semen left at the scene led police to the murderer.

In 2019, genealogists working on the case used genetic genealogy to zero in on two brothers as suspects. One of the brothers was ruled out because his DNA was already in CODIS and it wasn't a match to the semen at the scene. The second brother, Patrick Nicholas, had served time in prison for an attempted rape from 1983, but his DNA had never been entered into CODIS.

After surveilling Nicholas, investigators collected a cigarette that he'd tossed on the ground and were able to match DNA from the cigarette to the DNA found on Yarborough's clothes, ABC News reported.

After evading justice for over three decades, Patrick Nicholas was arrested and later found guilty in the murder of the teenager. On May 10, 2023, a jury in King County, Washington, where the murder took place, found Nicholas guilty of first and second-degree murder with sexual motivation.

Nicholas, now 59, was 27 at the time of the murder, according to the Federal Way Mirror. He had kept a copy of a 1994 newspaper that featured an article about Sarah, and he had a photo of the teen in his kitchen drawer which was found when he was arrested.

Sarah Yarborough’s family and friends still mourn the loss of the teen, but they are grateful that justice was finally served. Mary Beth Thome, a childhood friend of Sarah, said, “Nothing will bring Sarah back, but this is as much justice as we can all expect after so many years, and we’re really grateful the verdict was what it was.”

Thome told KOMO News, "She loved art, she loved to dance, what would she have become in those years that were taken from her? I think she would've been a beautiful person, and I think it's really sad that the world didn't get to see who she would've become."

Nicholas’ sentencing hearing is scheduled for May 25.

Next Up

Amish Teenager In Pennsylvania Found Dead After Abduction Caught On Surveillance Video

“I robbed the family of time and memories,” the killer told Linda Stoltzfoos’ loved ones at his sentencing.

DNA Ties Two Virginia College Students’ Homicides To ‘Back-To-School Killer’

One victim’s mother called Jesse Matthew Jr. "a serial rapist and murderer who had been hiding in plain sight."

Midwestern Civil War Buff May Be Serial Killer Connected To Dozens Of Females’ Deaths

Larry DeWayne Hall was identified as a suspect in a kidnapping after a witness took down his van’s license plate number.

Man Arrested After Tech CEO Found Murdered In Her Baltimore Apartment

Pava LaPere, a rising tech star in her twenties, was murdered in her Baltimore home. After a few days on the run, Jason Dean Billingsley, 32, was arrested and charged with her murder.

DNA From Under Victim’s Fingernails Leads To Arrest Of Las Vegas Murderer After 42 Years

The case of who murdered 25-year-old Sandra DiFelice went cold for over four decades until her daughter urged police to take another look at the case in 2021.

New Trial Date Set For Accused Murderer Of 14-Year-Old Wendy Jerome

Back in 1984, a 14-year-old was murdered while walking to her friend’s house to deliver a birthday card. Now, after nearly 40 years, her alleged murderer was identified through DNA and faces trial.

Garbage Collector Fatally Stabs Fashion Writer In Her Seaside Home

Prosecutor says Christopher McCowen had "familiarity" with who Christa Worthington was, where she lived, and the fact she lived alone.

After 37 Years, The Cold Case Murder Of Florida Nurse Teresa Lee Scalf Is Finally Solved

After nearly four decades, blood found at the 1986 murder scene has helped investigators positively identify Teresa Lee Scalf's killer.

Ohio Teenager Kills Boyfriend, Friend By Slamming Car Into Wall At 100 MPH

Mackenzie Shirilla, then 17, “had a mission, and she executed it with precision,” the judge said.

Oregon Man Arrested For 1974 Cold Case Murders Of Two Teen Boys

In 1974, Steven Paul Criss allegedly shot and killed two teenagers in Washington County, Oregon. Two years later, in 1976, he killed his commanding officer in the army with the same gun.