Fitbit Data Busted 90-Year-Old Man Accused Of Staging Stepdaughter’s Death

Surveillance video showed Karen Navarra’s driveway; police noted Anthony Aiello parked outside his stepdaughter’s house from 3:12 to 3:33 P.M. that day.

October 03, 2018

Anthony Aiello [San Jose Police Department]

Anthony Aiello [San Jose Police Department]

By: Aaron Rasmussen

SAN JOSE, CA — A Fitbit registering heart-rate data led police to arrest a 90-year-old man who is now accused of killing his stepdaughter and staging her death to look like a suicide.

According to ABC News, police conducting a welfare check on 67-year-old Karen Navarra on September 13 found her dead in her home. She had suffered lacerations to her head and neck and was clutching a kitchen knife in her hand.

While at first it appeared Navarra may have taken her own life, detectives began to suspect that someone had staged the scene. In fact, a medical examiner later determined the woman could not have made all the “multiple deep and intrusive wounds” by herself.

Police turned to Navarra’s stepdad, Anthony Aiello, for answers. Aiello claimed he had gone to see the daughter of his 92-year-old wife on September 8 to bring her pizza and biscotti. After about 15 minutes, he said, he left and returned home. He also told detectives that Navarra later drove by his house with someone in her front seat, honked, waved, and continued on her way.

After detectives pulled Aiello’s neighbor's surveillance videos, which showed Navarra was actually not in his area that day, the senior’s story began to fall apart — but it was a Fitbit found strapped to the dead woman's wrist that authorities said helped them crack the case.

Detectives checked the data recorded on Navarra’s Fitbit Alta HR and noticed her heart rate skyrocketed at 3:20 P.M. on September 8. The device showed her heart rate then rapidly declined and completely stopped at 3:28 P.M. Locating surveillance video that showed Navarra’s driveway, police noted Aiello was suspiciously parked outside his stepdaughter’s house from 3:12 P.M. to 3:33 P.M. that day.

"During the interview, Aiello was confronted about the information from Fitbit and the corresponding surveillance video indicating that his car was in the driveway,” officers wrote in a statement of facts. They then accused Aiello of murdering Navarra and fleeing the scene, but he "denied that he was present when she was killed and suggested that someone else might have been in the house."

Two bloody shirts were later located in Aiello’s garage. "He was told that the deposits of blood were not localized in one area and were more consistent with splatter," police claimed in the statement, adding Aiello said he often injured himself around the house. "Aiello indicated that he might have cut his hand and shaken it while he was wearing those shirts.”

Aiello has been charged with murder and ordered held without bail. He is next scheduled to appear in court on October 3.

Read more: ABC News, CBS5

Keep Reading

Next Up

Can You Guess Why This Woman Ended Up Behind Bars?

A heated situation boiled over for the Cincinnati resident.

The Murderous Pastor Who Craved Sex With The Dead

After killing Conway's mother, John D. White dressed the three-year-old in his Halloween costume and dropped the oblivious boy off to his father in a grocery store parking lot.

How A Podcast Helped Solve The Cold Case Murder Of A Georgia Beauty Queen

Payne Lindsay first found Tara Grinstead’s case in the GBI’s online cold-case files, and has stated that he became obsessed with the details.

Tejano Music Queen Selena Was Shot To Death By The President Of Her Fan Club

As Selena ran from the room, Yolanda Saldivar shot her in the back. Selena died in a hospital due to a loss of blood and cardiac arrest, two weeks before her 24th birthday.

Death House Landlady: Unexpected Serial Killer Dorothea Puente

The culprit was none other than the adorable gray-haired landlady, Dorothea Puente, who would make headlines as one of the most shocking serial killers in Sacramento history.

West Virginia Woman Hid Knife In Buttocks & Threatened To Drink Deputies' Blood

Jackie Fullmer threatened to stab deputies in the neck and watch their "blood drain as she drank it" while being transported.

Video: Woman Led Police On High-Speed Car Chase With Her Baby In The Back Seat

Police say that Caitlyn Rodriguez, who led police on a high-speed car chase with her baby in the car, had several outstanding warrants.