Father, Son Receive Life Sentences After They ‘Butchered And Discarded’ Young Mother

The two men did not want Nicole Montalvo to have custody of her child, prosecutors say.

August 03, 2021

33-year-old mother of one, Nicole Montalvo [screenshot via Fox 35 Orlando]

By: Aaron Rasmussen

A Florida judge has handed down life sentences to a father and son found guilty of second-degree murder, tampering with evidence and abuse of a human body in connection to the death of a mother nearly two years ago.

“I cannot ignore the brutality of your efforts to cover up that crime, or the pain it brought the family of Nicole Montalvo,” Judge Keith Carsons told the defendants: the victim’s ex-husband, Christopher Otero-Rivera, 33, and his father, Angel Rivera, 66, in an Osceola County court, according to Orlando television station WESH.

On October 21, 2019, Montalvo, 33, dropped her and Otero-Rivera’s 9-year-old son, Elijah, off at the Rivera family’s home in St. Cloud and vanished. Six days after Montalvo went missing, investigators located her dismembered and burned remains buried on the property, Tampa’s WFLA-TV reported.

“Immediately upon discovering flesh, the fleshy material, a foul odor was present,” Osceola County Sheriff's Office forensics investigator Emily Seda testified at trial.

Before Otero-Rivera and Rivera’s July 21 sentencing, several of Montalvo’s loved ones delivered impact statements. The victim’s sister, Christina Montalvo, told the court her grief is “an intense and deep pain that comes and goes,” WESH reported.

“Sometimes it feels like the grieving process is never ending, especially when it's an unexpected and traumatizing loss of your only sister,” she continued. “When people ask me what happened to Nicole, I've always said she passed away from an act of domestic violence.”

Steven Montalvo, who reportedly searched hours for his older sister the day she disappeared, said in court that she “should be here today” and he felt a sense of “terror and a loss for words.”

“She’ll never get to express the pain she feels, the pain that she felt, what she went through, everything that she had to endure, she should be the one speaking today,” he shared.

The murder victim’s twin brother, Edward Montalvo, said his sibling was “butchered and discarded, like she never mattered.”

Judge Carsons sentenced the father and son to life in prison for second-degree murder as well as another 15 years for dismembering a human body, and another five for tampering with evidence.

WESH reported the pair plan to appeal their sentences, citing statements from their attorneys.

Next Up

Man Filmed Crying After Locating Son’s Body 34 Years Ago Now Accused Of Murder

Justin Turner, 5, was found dead in 1989, two days after his father, Victor Lee Turner, and stepmother, Megan Turner, reported the boy missing.

6-Year-Old Found Dead Near Church Cemetery Finally Identified 23 Years Later

In 1999, a boy was found deceased in DeKalb County, Georgia. For over two decades, the child remained nameless until July 2022, when police announced the child’s identity as William DaShawn Hamilton.

Indiana Man Who Murdered His Parents Claimed They Had Suicide Pact

“I never would have in a million years thought that he would have ever done anything like this,” says the convicted killer’s aunt.

Digital Technology Helps Solve Murder Of California Nurse Found Brutally Stabbed

“I felt that there was something broken in that person,” one official said of discovering who had committed the crime.

Dog DNA Helped Solve Case Of Illinois Woman Whose Body Was Found Dismembered In Lake

23-year-old Karyn Hearn Slover, the mother of a 3-year-old son, was about to move out of state to pursue modeling when she was murdered.

Son Of TikTok Star 'Mama Tot' Was Murdered A Day Before His 19th Birthday

Randon Lee was shot and killed at a gas station in Prichard, Alabama on June 24, 2022 — one day before what would’ve been his 19th birthday.

Accident Or Murder? Man Fleeing House Fire Dies After His Wife Strikes Him With Vehicle

“I don’t know why he didn’t survive,” Linda Stermer says of her husband Todd’s grisly 2007 death in Michigan.

New Jersey Teenager ‘Casually’ Slaughtered His Family During New Year’s Eve Party

“He killed them because he could,” the prosecutor said of Scott Kologi fatally shooting his parents, sister, and grandfather’s partner on Dec. 31, 2017.

Florida Mom Shot And Killed After Knocking On Neighbor’s Door

Ajike ‘AJ’ Owens was shot after knocking on the door of a neighbor who complained about the victim’s children playing in the neighborhood and reportedly used racist slurs against the family.

Husband Of Missing Mother Who Searched 'How To Get Away With Murder’ Pleads Guilty To Her Murder

55-year-old Elizabeth Capaldi was reported missing on Oct. 12, 2022. In April 2023, her husband pleaded guilty to strangling and dismembering her, and hiding her remains.