Update: Accused Cannibal Killer Joseph Oberhansley Won’t Face Death Penalty

Prosecutors said they withdrew capital punishment as the defendant's alleged mental-health issues could lead to a reversal of a guilty verdict.

September 21, 2020
Mug shot of Joseph Oberhansley [Clark County Sheriff’s Office]

Photo by: Mug shot of Joseph Oberhansley [Clark County Sheriff’s Office]

Mug shot of Joseph Oberhansley [Clark County Sheriff’s Office]

By: Mike McPadden

UPDATE 9/21/20

The Indiana man who was accused of killing his ex-girlfriend and mutilating and consuming parts of her body has been found guilty of murder.

According to police, on Sept. 11, 2014, Joseph Oberhansley, 39, confessed he broke into the home of Tammy Jo Blanton, stabbed her to death and used an electric saw to remove portions of her brain, heart and lungs, some of which he cooked and ate.

Oberhansley later retracted the confession and then claimed two men had knocked him out and stabbed the 46-year-old woman to death.

Over the next six years, Oberhansley’s trial was delayed multiple times, including in 2016, when his defense team was granted more time to prepare. The following year, he underwent mental health treatment after he was ruled incompetent to stand trial.

During his six-day trial that started on Sept. 11 at Clark County Circuit Court in Jeffersonville, Indiana, Oberhansley took the stand and claimed he did not know who had consumed some of Blanton’s organs.

“She suffered so many indignities that night,” Clark County Prosecutor Jeremy Mull told the court during closing arguments, the Courier Journal reported. “She was terrified, she was stabbed, she was dismembered, she was eaten and she was raped. And the justice for each of those acts of indignities is important if it is proven. … It’s what justice demands.”

Oberhansley reportedly had rejected his defense attorneys’ earlier advice to plead insanity, and jurors found him guilty of murder and burglary but acquitted him of a rape charge. He now faces the possibility of spending the rest of his life behind bars.

Oberhansley previously served a 12-year sentence in Utah for manslaughter after he killed his teenage girlfriend and shot his mother in a meth-fueled rage, according to the Courier Journal.

In July 2012, Oberhansley, out on parole, moved to Indiana to be near his mother, who had forgiven him.

He began dating Blanton in spring 2014, but she became frightened of him and broke off the relationship just days before he took her life.

Blanton’s father, Darry Harbin, has said his daughter “was trying to give the man a chance.”


JEFFERSONVILLE, IN — An Indiana man facing trial for allegedly killing, mutilating, and eating various body parts of his ex-girlfriend won’t face the death penalty, according to a document filed by prosecutors in Clark County Circuit Court.

Joseph Oberhansley, 38, stands accused in the September 2014 murder of Tammy Jo Blanton, 46. According to police, Blanton had broken up with Oberhansley about a month earlier. He reportedly showed up at her house on September 11 and attacked her.

After Blanton failed to report to work, officers said they were called to check on her. Upon seeing the back door broken, the responders said they entered Blanton’s residence and discovered her mutilated body under a camping tent in her bathtub.

The arrest affidavit also claims police found “a plate with what appeared to be skull bone and blood on it,” as well as a skillet and a pair of tongs alleged to have had blood on them.

According to multiple media sources describing Oberhansley as an accused “cannibal,” authorities have theorized that he may have eaten parts of Blanton’s body.

Authorities additionally reported that parts of Blanton’s heart, lungs, and brain were missing, with the affidavit stating, “The front of the victim's skull appeared to have been crushed and brain tissue appeared scattered around the bathtub."

An autopsy reportedly determined that Blanton died from sharp-force trauma to the head.

Investigators said they tracked down and questioned Oberhansley and that he denied killing Blanton, but later admitted to breaking into her home and repeatedly stabbing her body.

In that same interview, police said, Oberhansley allegedly also claimed he had chased two armed black men out of Blanton’s residence, said he could hear her thoughts, and mentioned the Greek god Zeus, along with a being who had a third eye in his forehead.

Oberhansley has since been charged with murder, rape, and burglary. He has reportedly requested that his attorneys not plead insanity or any other mental-health defense, as he believes that would come off as an admission of guilt.

On June 12, a judge reportedly issued an order supporting Oberhansley’s request and he has been deemed competent to stand trial.

After withdrawing the death penalty, Clark County Prosecutor Jeremy Mull issued a statement Tuesday declaring that the defendant’s possible mental-health issues would increase the chances of a reversal of a capital sentence upon appeal and, in fact, could jeopardize any guilty verdict.

Mull wrote, "Because of the psychiatric evidence that's been produced and put on the record in this case, I believe that it would be virtually impossible to see any death penalty in this case upheld in the federal courts…. Further, pursuing the death penalty in this case in light of this psychiatric evidence would present a substantial risk that any guilty verdict itself, in addition to the death penalty, would be reversed.”

Brent Westerfield, one of Oberhansley’s lawyers, responded to the announcement by telling a reporter, “I think it's the right decision that the prosecutor made. I think that the history of the case shows Mr. Oberhansley is severely mentally ill. Even though right now he's been found competent, he still is seriously mentally ill.”

Instead, prosecutors said the state will seek to put Oberhansley behind bars for life without the possibility of parole. Jury selection is scheduled to begin August 19.

Next Up

Florida Father Charged With Double Homicide Of Girlfriend, Toddler Found Dead In Alligator's Mouth

Thomas Mosley, 21, allegedly stabbed his girlfriend to death before throwing their 2-year-old son into a lake, where his body was later found inside an alligator’s mouth.

New Hampshire Man Convicted Of Fatally Stabbing Ex-Girlfriend At Her Book Club Meeting

31-year-old Amanda Dabrowski broke up with her co-worker after dating him for three months, and he started stalking her. After one attempt at murdering her, he stabbed her to death inside a restaurant in July 2019.

Omaima Nelson: The Model Who Killed, Castrated & Ate Her Husband For Thanksgiving

On Thanksgiving Day 1991, Nelson unleashed her fury, she claimed, over the sexual terror and other abuses to which her husband Bill had subjected her.

Secret Affair Led To Brutal Murder Of Delaware Woman Found With Neck Cut

The death of churchgoing grandmother Mary Anderson shocked her local community.

True Crime News Roundup: Texas Man Accused of Kidnapping and Torturing Woman He Met On Dating App

Plus: Utah family of 8 found fatally shot in murder-suicide; Probable cause affidavit released for University of Idaho murder case.

The Horrific Murder Of Deborah Brandão

In August 2023, Danelo Souza Cavalcante broke out of jail and caused a massive manhunt that ended in his successful recapture, but many don’t know about the horrifically cruel crime that sent him to jail.

True Crime News Roundup: Chicago Woman Accused Of Killing And Dismembering Her Landlord

Plus: Parkland mass shooter to be sentenced to life; 15-year-old allegedly kills five in Raleigh shooting spree; Alex Jones ordered to pay $1 billion in damages to Sandy Hook victim families.

Teen Girl Allegedly Killed By Ex-Boyfriend On Class Trip To Myrtle Beach

Natalie Martin went to Myrtle Beach to celebrate her recent high school graduation but her trip was cut tragically short on June 7, 2023, when she was found dead in a rental home she was sharing with friends.

Florida Woman Allegedly Murders Roommate, Pours Soda On Herself To Destroy Evidence

Nichole Maks, 35, allegedly murdered her 79-year-old roommate at the Daytona Beach home they shared and tried to cover up the evidence by pouring Diet Mountain Dew on herself.

‘Their Innocence Was So Crystal Clear’: Couple Cleared Of Murdering 4-Year-Old Girl In ‘87

“I'm just happy to be out of this mess, which has cost me half of my life for nothing,” Joyce Watkins says.