A Look Back at the Teenage 'Thrill Killer' Who Slit the Throat of a 9-Year-Old Girl

October 20, 2017
By: Catherine Townsend
Alyssa Bustamante

Alyssa Bustamante

Photo by: Women's Eastern Reception Diagnostic & Correctional Center

Women's Eastern Reception Diagnostic & Correctional Center

Alyssa Bustamante

ST. MARTINS, MO — On the evening of October 21, 2009, 15-year-old Alyssa Bustamante told her nine-year-old neighbor in the small town of St. Martins, Missouri, that she had a surprise for her.

Elizabeth Olten followed Bustamante to the woods, where she viciously attacked the little girl, stabbing her repeatedly and slitting her throat. After the kill, she calmly buried the fourth grader’s body in a hole she had dug on a day off from school — and went to church.

Shockingly, investigators would later reveal that the teen killed her young victim for the thrill of it. “Ultimately, she stated she wanted to know what it felt like,” Missouri State Highway Patrol Sergeant David Rice, who heard Bustamante’s confession, testified during a court hearing.

FBI agents seized a journal from Bustamante’s bedroom during a search of her family’s home the day after Elizabeth went missing, and found entires written on the night of the killing describing it as “ahmazing” and a “pretty enjoyable” experience.

A passage from the teen’s journal, which was referenced during her murder trial, read:

“I just f***ing killed someone. I strangled them and slit their throat and stabbed them now they’re dead. I don’t know how to feel atm [at the moment]. It was ahmazing. As soon as you get over the “ohmygawd I can’t do this” feeling, it’s pretty enjoyable. I’m kinda nervous and shaky though right now. Kay, I gotta go to church now…lol,”

Elizabeth’s mother, Patty Preiss, said that her daughter left at around 5 P.M. on the day she went missing after begging to go play with Bustamante’s younger sister. She never came home.

The case made national headlines partly due to the brutality of the crime — and also due to Bustamante’s social-media profile. On a (now deleted) YouTube page in her name, she listed one of her hobbies as “killing people.” The page also featured footage of Bustamante and one of her brothers shocking themselves on an electrified fence.

On her Facebook page, several images were posted of her with red smeared lipstick and scary-looking black kabuki-style makeup over her eyes. As the case unfolded, Bustamante’s journal and social-media profiles continued to provide a picture of a very disturbed mind.

She confessed to being depressed and cutting herself, and a week before the murder she wrote that she was unable to use her cell phone because the charger had died — so could not talk to anyone about the depression and rage she was feeling.

During the trial, Bustamante’s attorneys argued that she had had a troubled childhood and deserved a degree of leniency. At an earlier hearing, juvenile justice officials testified that the troubled teen had attempted to commit suicide in 2007 and had been receiving treatment for depression. But Preiss called Bustamante an “evil monster” and “not even human,” adding: “I hate her, I hate everything about her.”

After her arrest, Bustamante was charged with first-degree murder. In court, she expressed remorse to Olten’s family, saying, “I know words can never be enough and they can never adequately describe how horribly I feel for all of this. If I could give my life to get her back I would. I’m sorry.”

In 2012, Bustamante was sentenced to life in prison with the possibility of parole — which means that she could walk free one day.

Watch Now:

Next Up

Omaima Nelson: The Model Who Killed, Castrated & Ate Her Husband For Thanksgiving

On Thanksgiving Day 1991, Nelson unleashed her fury, she claimed, over the sexual terror and other abuses to which her husband Bill had subjected her.

Florida Teen Sentenced To Life For Murder Of 13-Year-Old Classmate Stabbed 114 Times

Aiden Fucci allegedly told people “he was going to kill someone by taking them in the woods and stabbing them,” authorities said.

UPDATE: ‘In Pursuit with John Walsh’ Fugitive John Blauvelt Arrested In Oregon

Investigators said John Blauvelt, 33, who was AWOL from the Army, was on the run for six years after allegedly killing his wife. U.S. Marshals said that during the arrest, Blauvelt was going by the name "Ben Klein".

Florida Father Charged With Double Homicide Of Girlfriend, Toddler Found Dead In Alligator's Mouth

Thomas Mosley, 21, allegedly stabbed his girlfriend to death before throwing their 2-year-old son into a lake, where his body was later found inside an alligator’s mouth.

True Crime News Roundup: Missing California Woman Found Dead In Remote Woods, Ex-Husband Arrested

Plus: Four University of Idaho students brutally murdered; Pregnant Florida mom found shot; Gabby Petito’s family awarded $3 million in lawsuit; Parents of boy found dead in washing machine charged with his murder.

The Twists And Turns Of The Infamous Susan Smith Case

On October 25, 1994, the 23-year-old South Carolina mother drowned her two young children.

Colorado Man Allegedly Kills Teen Coworker In Break Room After She Rejected His Advances

Riley Whitelaw, 17, had previously expressed concerns about her 28-year-old coworker Joshua Johnson, whom she said made her feel uncomfortable.

UPDATE: Fugitive Leticia Smith from ‘In Pursuit With John Walsh’ Captured In Mexico

Authorities confirm former fugitive, Leticia Smith was extradited from Mexico to California. Smith will face charges for allegedly killing her husband, Antione Smith.

5 Recent Developments Involving Serial Killer Clown John Wayne Gacy

The case of the monster who murdered dozens of boys and young men continues to evolve today.

True Crime News Roundup: Elderly Man Missing For Months Found Dead In Trash Can Outside His Home

Plus: NYC sixth-grader struck and killed by stray bullet; New Hampshire police search for person of interest in double homicide; Fyre Festival fraudster released early from prison; and manhunt continues for escaped Texas prisoner.