4 Times Casey Anthony's Story Didn’t Match The Facts

On June 16, 2008, Casey Anthony took her daughter Caylee and left the Orlando, Florida, home of Casey’s parents, George and Cindy Anthony. Caylee was never seen alive again.

November 15, 2022
By: Crime Feed Staff
Casey Anthony listens during testimony in her murder trial at the Orange County Courthouse in Orlando, Florida, Thursday, June 30, 2011.

On June 16, 2008, Casey Anthony took her daughter Caylee and left the Orlando, Florida, home of Casey’s parents, George and Cindy Anthony. Caylee was never seen alive again.

Photo by: Getty Images

Getty Images

Much of the firestorm surrounding the 2008 disappearance and death of two-year-old Caylee Anthony was infamously inflamed by the reported falsehoods and fabrications of Casey Anthony, the toddler’s mother who eventually stood trial for the girl’s murder — and beat the rap.

Time after time, police and prosecutors seemed to catch Casey Anthony engaged in deception before, during, and after the courtroom proceedings that so powerfully enraptured and often infuriated the press and the public.

Still, on July 5, 2011, a jury ruled that Casey's guilt in Caylee’s killing had not been proven beyond a reasonable doubt, and the woman who had been coined by the public as “Tot Mom” won an acquittal.

Even if Casey didn’t kill Caylee, her path to freedom was reportedly not one built on honesty. Here are four crucial incidents wherein Casey Anthony’s claims did not match up with reality.

Casey claimed she spoke to Caylee — after the little girl had died

The tragic saga is said to have commenced on June 16, 2008, when Casey Anthony took Caylee and left the Orlando, Florida, home of Casey’s parents, George and Cindy Anthony. For the next 31 days, George and Cindy did not see Casey or Caylee. When asked what was up, Casey said she was on work detail in Tampa Bay.

The mystery deepened after George got a notice to pick up Casey’s car from an impound lot, and noted that the interior smelled like a decomposing body. On July 15, Cindy Anthony called the police to report Caylee missing.

Casey immediately claimed that Caylee had been abducted and that she’d just spoken with her on the phone, saying:

“She was excited to talk to me. She said, ‘Hi, mommy!’… Today was the first time I have heard her voice in over four weeks. After 31 days, I know that all that matters is getting my daughter back.”

Investigators later determined that Casey had already been dead for weeks. In fact, even Casey’s defense conceded that to be true, claiming that Caylee drowned in the family’s swimming pool on June 16.

Casey blamed it on her babysitter — who wasn't her babysitter

During her 31 days away, Casey occasionally claimed that she left Caylee with a babysitter named Zenaida Fernandez-Gonzalez, who she said went by “Zanny the Nanny.” She further stated that Zanny the Nanny took off with Caylee and had been holding her captive.

In identifying Zanny, Casey said they had met through a mutual friend named Jeffery Michael Hopkins. Casey mentioned that she dated Hopkins briefly, and that Zanny was his current girlfriend. She also described Zanny’s apartment in great detail and told police:

“This is the honest to God’s truth. I don’t know where [Caylee] is. The last person that I saw her with is Zenaida.”

In addition, Casey said that Hopkins was rich, worked for Nickelodeon, and that his son Zachary frequently played with Caylee. None of this was true.

When police asked for contact info, Casey told them, “Zenaida’s number has switched a couple times, and Jeff’s number changed.”

Zenaida Fernandez-Gonzalez did prove to be an actual person, but “Zanny the Nanny” did not. The real Fernandez-Gonazelz had no relationship whatsoever with Casey, Caylee, or Jeff Hopkins. She later sued Casey Anthony for defamation.

Jeff Hopkins attended middle school with Casey Anthony. Except for a single time years earlier when they ran into one another at a bar, he had not been in touch with her since then. He also didn’t have any children and had never met anyone named Zenaida Fernandez-Gonzalez.

Casey said she worked at Universal Studios — when she was unemployed

For years, George and Cindy Anthony believed their daughter was working as an event planner at Universal Studios. She actually did have a job on the lot four years prior, with a Universal subcontractor. After that, Casey simply pretended to still be employed.

The lie deepened as Casey made up coworkers, notably a friend named Juliette Lewis. Casey said that Lewis did a lot of volunteer work, prompting Cindy to drop by Universal to meet with Lewis about a fundraiser. Cindy waited 90 minutes. Lewis never showed. Casey explained that Lewis had moved to New York. Later, Universal said the company had no record of an employee named Juliette Lewis.

Casey attempted to keep up the Universal job ruse during police questioning. At one point, officers accompanied her to the studio and asked to see her office. Casey led them around on a walk for a while before finally breaking down and admitting she no longer worked there.

Casey lied about not lying

Even though she dodged a guilty murder verdict and a potential death sentence, Casey Anthony did get convicted and sentenced to four years in July 2011 for lying under oath. Because she had already served three years, she was released from prison shortly thereafter.

Still, it’s reported that the lies may have continued.

While being deposed in 2014 in regard to the defamation suit filed by Zenaida Fernandez-Gonzalez, Casey continued to insist that “Zanny the Nanny” was real. She said that she met Zanny at Universal Studios in 2006 and that she babysat for Caylee just once. Most notably, Casey did finally admit that she had made up the story about dropping Caylee off with Zanny the day of the disappearance, despite telling police it was “the God’s honest truth.”

When asked if the term “Zanny the Nanny” could be, in fact, a code for the drug Xanax, which could have been used to knock out little Caylee, an upset Casey categorically denied it.

Casey further added that she still did not know how to contact Zanny the Nanny and that she never implicated the plaintiff Zenaida Fernandez-Gonzalez in the crime, stating emphatically:

“That’s never been the case and that will never be the truth. So let’s get that straight right here and now. You can ask a hundred more ridiculous questions. I’m not going to answer them. I’m done here.”

For more on this case, stream Casey Anthony: An American Murder Mystery on discovery+.

Next Up

Inside The Tragic Hart Family Murder-Suicide Crash

Jennifer and Sarah Hart killed themselves and murdered their six adopted children in 2018 by driving their SUV off a cliff in California.

Hospital Officials Alerted Police When A Young Boy’s Illness Seemed Like Intentional Harm

Lacey Spears’ childhood friends back in Alabama were heartbroken when they heard about the death of her 5-year-old son.

True Crime News Roundup: Young NYC Mother Fatally Shot While Pushing Newborn In Stroller

Plus: Gabby Petito’s mother “fed up” with “narcissist” killer Brian Laundrie; search continues for missing Georgia teen with special needs; Arizona grandmother solves her own murder; warrant connected to Emmett Till lynching case discovered in Mississippi courthouse.

Man Who Strangled Wife In Hot Tub Killed His First Spouse In Bath Four Years Earlier

“I think he’s like a cancer,” says the son of convicted murderer Timothy Boczkowski. “And I do think if he got out, he would kill again.”

Dog DNA Helped Solve Case Of Illinois Woman Whose Body Was Found Dismembered In Lake

23-year-old Karyn Hearn Slover, the mother of a 3-year-old son, was about to move out of state to pursue modeling when she was murdered.

Man Bludgeoned His 77-Year-Old Grandmother To Death, Burned Her Body

“Anthony Sena almost got away with this murder,” a detective says of Susan Hernandez’s death.

Two Families Were Torn Apart After A Heinous Tennessee Triple Murder

The lead investigator was moved to tears as he described the crime scene as “360 degrees of terror.”

Family Claims FBI Botched Investigation Of Indigenous Woman’s Death

“I can't bear any of my tribal members to go through what I went through,” says Ashlea Aldrich’s mother.

True Crime News Roundup: Millionaire Robert Durst On Trial For Murder

A woman allegedly killed her newborn after delivering; the lawyer whose wife and son were murdered in June was shot in the head; and a toddler died after suspects police believe are students shot up his family’s home.

True Crime News Roundup: Brittney Griner Transferred To Russian Penal Colony

Plus: Colorado police launch new probe into JonBenet Ramsey case; Woman sentenced to life for murdering woman to steal her baby; California megachurch leader accused of torturing young daughter; and Texas medical examiner murdered at work by her estranged husband.