Missouri Pair Allegedly Kidnapped Woman, Held Her Captive In Cage, Authorities Say

An anonymous tipster reportedly sent the FBI a photo of the victim restrained and partially nude.

Cassidy Rainwater has blonde hair and is wearing black frame glasses and a black headband standing in front of a blue background

Cassidy Rainwater

Photo by: Dallas County Sheriff's Office

Dallas County Sheriff's Office

Cassidy Rainwater

By: Aaron Rasmussen

One of the Missouri men accused of kidnapping a woman and holding her captive in a cage on a rundown Ozarks property has been sentenced to life in prison for her kidnapping, death, and dismemberment.

Cassidy Rainwater, 33, vanished in July 2021 and family filed a missing person’s report late the following month. A Dallas County Sheriff’s Office deputy investigating Rainwater’s disappearance determined she was last in contact with then 58-year-old James D. Phelps.

Phelps allegedly claimed in an interview that the missing woman had been living in a loft on his rented 3-acre Lebanon property “until she could get back on her feet” — but he said she was no longer there.

“James told me she was talking about going to Colorado,” the deputy wrote in a probable cause document, according to The Kansas City Star.

Phelps allegedly also claimed Rainwater met a vehicle at the end of his driveway in the middle of the night and that was the last time he heard from her, according to court documents.

None of Rainwater’s personal possessions were in the loft and it appeared “stripped,” investigators noted.

In mid-September 2021, the court documents state, an anonymous tipster sent the FBI office in Kansas City a photo of Rainwater partially nude and in a cage, and the agents contacted Dallas County law enforcement officials. Deputies seized Phelps’ cell phone after taking him into custody and they allegedly discovered seven photos showing Rainwater restrained in the cage.

The sheriff’s office then questioned a second man, then 56-year-old Timothy L. Norton, in connection to Rainwater’s disappearance. Court documents obtained by the Springfield News-Leader allege Norton told investigators Phelps asked for his help restraining Rainwater and that Norton went to his property and “did physically confine” the woman by “holding her down for a substantial period of time.”

Norton told police officers that after Rainwater was dead, he and Phelps took her body outside and dismembered her.

Prosecutors charged Phelps and Norton with kidnapping over the disappearance of Rainwater and in November, the Dallas County prosecutor filed first-degree murder charges against Phelps and Norton in Rainwater’s death.

The cabin Phelps was living in before his arrest burned to the ground in October 2021. The Springfield Fire Department found two incendiary devices constructed from mortar tubes, coiled fuzes and balloons as well as a tripwire, WDAF-TV reported.

In April 2023, Phelps entered an Alford plea for first-degree murder. The Alford plea means Phelps acknowledges he would be found guilty during a trial, but he maintains his innocence. As a result, he was sentenced to life without parole.

Norton is still awaiting trial on charges of first-degree murder, kidnapping, and abandonment of a corpse.

*This article was originally published on October 15, 2021 and updated on May 8, 2023.

Next Up

A Massachusetts College Student’s 1986 Cold Case Murder Was Finally Solved 36 Years Later

20-year-old Claire Gravel spent the night of June 29, 1986 with friends at a pub. After she was dropped off at her Salem apartment early the next morning, she was never seen alive again.

Colorado Security Guard Arrested For Murder Found With Severed Hand In His Pocket

After police in Pueblo, Colorado, discovered the decapitated body of a woman in a creek, they arrested a security guard who was found with a severed hand in his pocket.

Fugitive Captured In Mexico After Deadly Shooting

In August 2022, U.S. Marshals tracked Jonathan Dorado to Tijuana, Mexico where he was arrested and extradited back to the United States. Dorado is behind bars at the Merced County Jail in California where he faces murder and attempted murder charges.

Who Was Notorious Jewel Thief Jack “Murph The Surf” Murphy?

Not all of the details Murphy shared about his life can be verified, but what we know to be true is a fascinating tale about a daytime surfer who moonlighted as a high-end thief.

Suspect Arrested In Connection With 1987 Cold Case Murder Of Missouri Woman

Police say solving the cold case is a “shining example of the importance of never giving up” and “pursuing justice relentlessly.”

Memphis Woman Says Police Failed To Investigate Her 2021 Rape By Eliza Fletcher’s Killer

DNA from a 2021 rape kit was not determined to match Cleotha Henderson until Sept. 5, 2022, three days after he is accused of kidnapping and murdering Fletcher.

The Shocking Kidnapping And Murder Of California Family Of Four And Other True Crime News

On Oct. 3, four members of a California family were kidnapped outside their business near Merced. Two days later, their bodies were found.

Virginia Woman In D.C. For A Concert Murdered In Hotel Room

Christy Bautista reportedly yelled for help before she was stabbed to death on March 31 inside a hotel room in Washington, D.C.

Man Confesses To Killing His Uber Driver, Posting A Video Of The Attack On Facebook

A 29-year-old man allegedly told police he had wanted to kill someone on Dec. 8 and that he didn’t pick his victim, “Uber picked her.”

5 Questions The Gabby Petito Case Brought Up About Domestic Violence

The murder of 22-year-old Gabby Petito at the hands of her boyfriend, Brian Laundrie, sparked a national conversation about the signs of domestic abuse.