New Mexico Dad Takes Baby & Girlfriend On Halloween Costume Heist

Seth McKelvy-Cothren allegedly used fake credit cards to buy bags full of pricey treats.

October 30, 2018
Seth McKelvy-Cothren [Albuquerque Police Department]; screenshot from video [KRQE]

Seth McKelvy-Cothren [Albuquerque Police Department]; screenshot from video [KRQE]

Seth McKelvy-Cothren [Albuquerque Police Department]; screenshot from video [KRQE]

By: Aaron Rasmussen

ALBUQUERQUE, NM — A New Mexico man pulling tricks on a chain of Halloween costume shops got caught using fake credit and gift cards to buy bags full of costly outfits and decorations.

According to the Albuquerque Police Department, Seth McKelvy-Cothren hit the Spirit Halloween Store on October 24 and stocked up on $1,300 worth of goodies. He allegedly paid for his haul with a bogus card. After his successful shoplifting spree, he returned the following day and did it again, leaving the store with additional merchandise.

Cops claim McKelvy-Cothren then made his stealing a family affair.

The manager of a second Spirit Halloween location in the city told KRQE that McKelvy-Cothren and his girlfriend, Lona Armstrong, came to her store with their five-month-old son in tow this time.

They scooped up more items, and he handed over a credit card containing no name or numbers, arousing employees' suspicions.

"When we went to scan it, it actually didn't even scan or work,” said the unidentified manager. “He was like, ‘Well I know the credit card number,’ and we're like, ‘We can't do that.’"

But the manager could call the cops, who caught up with the family “down the road.”

“From what I heard, he had several different credit cards in his car,” noted the Halloween Spirit manager.

Police also searched Armstrong and found gift cards stuffed in her bra.

Both McKelvy-Cothren and Armstrong have been charged with conspiracy to commit fraud and tampering with evidence. The father faces an additional charge of identity theft.

"This is merchandise that you don't need ,and it is a little pricey, so [thieves] do come in here and try to get away with $40 to $50 costumes a lot," said the store manager. "We're onto this and we do want it to stop."

Read more: KRQE

Next Up

5 Key Takeaways From The Fraud Trial Of Theranos Founder Elizabeth Holmes

The former business woman could face up to 20 years in prison if convicted of the charges against her.

Unlicensed Mother, Daughter Accused Of Murder After Botched Butt Lift

Libby Adame and Alicia Galaz allegedly recruited new clients on Instagram and charged $14,000 for three sessions, police say.

Holy Heist: The Tangled Web Of A Priest, A Retired Cop, And An Armored Truck Robbery

A January 1993 heist started 10 years prior to the actual crime, according to the FBI agents who investigated the robbery of a Brink’s armored car depot.

True Crime News Roundup: George Floyd’s 4-Year-Old Grandniece Shot While Sleeping In Bed

Plus: Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes is found guilty of fraud; investigators crack the 1995 cold case murder of a Georgia schoolgirl; police name a suspect in the shooting death of Memphis rapper Young Dolph; and a judge overturns a Pennsylvania man’s murder conviction after 37 years.

True Crime News Roundup: Prince Andrew Stripped Of Military Titles After Judge Allows Sex Abuse Case To Proceed

Plus: A Chicago mother is arrested in connection to the murder of her 6-year-old son; the convicted killer Robert Durst dies at age 78; Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes’ sentencing date is set; and an LGBTQ+ rights movement hero is found dead in a Florida landfill.

True Crime News Roundup: Gabby Petito’s Body Found, Boyfriend Remains Missing

A 16-year-old boy pleads guilty to murdering NYC college student Tessa Majors; Britney Spears gets closer to ending her conservatorship; and the Elizabeth Holmes federal Theranos fraud trial continues.

Murdaugh Family Mystery: Investigators To Exhume Body Of Former Housekeeper

Gloria Satterfield died after a fall at the home of her boss, Alex Murdaugh, who now admits he stole $4.3 million in insurance proceeds from her sons.

Lip Balm, Air Vents & Mail Bags: Inside Richard Lee McNair’s Infamous Prison Breakouts

‘He is about the smartest person I’ve ever met,’ his brother once said.

Teen Confesses To Killing Pop Smoke Over A Rolex, LAPD Says

Detectives reveal how they were able to identify multiple suspects after the rapper's death.

Why Did It Take 15 Years To Prove An NFL Player Killed A California Millionaire?

A love triangle gone wrong left a millionaire dead and a football star behind bars for life.