Prison Nurse Allegedly Killed Husband With Antifreeze So She Could Marry Inmate

Police have stated that a possible motive for the murder could have been Amy Murray’s alleged relationship with Eugene Claypool, who is serving a life sentence for murder.

February 12, 2019

Amy Murray [Miller County Sheriff's Office]

Amy Murray [Miller County Sheriff's Office]

By: Catherine Townsend

JEFFERSON CITY, MO — A prison nurse is accused of fatally poisoning her husband with antifreeze so that she could marry an inmate with whom she allegedly had a relationship.

Amy Murray, 40, was arrested on Thursday and charged with first-degree murder in connection with the death of her husband, Joshua Murray. She was also charged with second-degree arson, tampering with physical evidence, and armed criminal action.

Police found the body of Joshua at the couple’s home in Iberia on December 11. The house had been burned, and investigators have said that they believe Amy used accelerant to start a fire in order to cover up her crime.

Police said autopsy results indicated that Joshua Murray died before the fire began, according to the Miller County Sheriff's Office.

In shades of the infamous Dannemora case, investigators believe that a possible motive for the murder could have been Amy’s alleged relationship with Eugene Claypool, who is serving a life sentence for murder.

Eugene Claypool [Missouri Department of Corrections]

Eugene Claypool [Missouri Department of Corrections]

In her role as a nurse at the Jefferson City Correctional Center, she became involved in a romantic relationship with Claypool, according to authorities, and even planned to marry Claypool.

After setting the fire, she fled the home with her 11-year-old son, according to probable-cause documents obtained by local news outlets.

Amy told investigators that she'd gone to McDonald's, and came home to find the house on fire. She explained that the smoke was too heavy for her to go inside.

Miller County Sheriff Louie Gregoire told KMIZ that the sheriff’s office detectives and investigators from the fire marshal’s office determined that the fire appeared “suspicious.”

Investigators also found clues in phone conversations between Amy and Claypool that referred to “having a life now that Joshua Murray was deceased and out of the picture,” according to probable-cause documents obtained by Lake Expo.

Following her arrest, Murray was being held at the Miller County Adult Detention Center on a $750,000 bond.

Next Up

Deadly Dads: 5 Fathers Who Killed Their Own Kids

Give your dad a call this Father’s Day … and give thanks you weren’t born to one of these monsters.

Black Widow Grandma Charged With Murder Of Husband Whose Scalp Was Found In A Bag

Michael Harris said his grandmother often talked about the best way to get rid of a body, including telling him that you have to stab a corpse before putting it into water so that it won't float, and telling him that a perpetrator could use a victim's heart medication to make it appear as though they had a heart attack.

Captured! Luis Frias: Wanted For Stabbing Janett Reyna 41 Times In Front Of Their 3 Children

Monique Hudson tells In Pursuit, “It was a really strong, strong smell [of blood] … there was blood everywhere. I never really smelled blood, that's a smell you can't mistake or forget.”

Harold ‘Butch’ Knight: 'I Strangled Her; She’s Dead & Laying On The Living Room Floor.'

In a package sent to the victim's mother after her murder, Knight included $2,000 to cover the cost of cremating his wife, because he said that’s what she had wanted.

When Gerald 'Mike' Bullinger’s Secret Lives Intersected, The Result Was Deadly

Gerald Michael Bullinger seemed to be a loving, doting boyfriend who wanted his family to have it all. No one but Bullinger knew it was all a ruse. He was living a double life, and when he was finally exposed, everyone in his path was taken out.

Robert Durst's 'Crime Family' Helped Him Cover Up Wife's Murder, Lawsuit Alleges

The lawsuit alleges that Kathie had planned to expose the Durst family's illegal business dealings, according to the wrongful death suit.

Caught! Peter Chadwick, Millionaire Fugitive Wanted For His Wife's Murder, Captured

Prosecutors stated that they believe Peter Chadwick strangled his wife after “a dispute regarding a possible divorce and related financial issues.”

Wife Charged With Husband's Murder, On The Run With 2 Daughters

Leticia Smith left the home with their two young daughters, four-year-old Abigail and eight-year-old Isabell. The family was traveling in a 2010 silver four-door Honda Accord with license plate 7FBT742.