May 29, 2015: Eighteen days after Tiffany Sayre's disappearance.

Tiffany Sayre, a 26-year-old mother of two, was last seen alive around midnight on May 11, 2015. Her body was found on June 20, 2015, in a culvert along a rural highway. Her manner of death is Homicidal Violence and her case remains open.

While searching for the fifth missing woman, another body is found. With the help of an anonymous tip, police are onto a possible suspect within hours. The community digs in once again on the possibility of a serial killer.

After discovering one of the missing women was friends with one of the women found dead, police redouble their efforts to find the missing woman. A person of interest is considered when the news of another missing girl sends Chillicothe into a panic.

When Diana spoke to her daughter Wanda Lemons on October 2, 2014, everything seemed to be on track. But then Wanda went silent. At first, a tip that she caught a ride to Texas gives law enforcement hope that she might be alive. But further investigation into her case soon makes investigators think otherwise.