New information leads to a new suspect decades after a couple are murdered.
13-year-old Tara Calico goes for a bike ride, but never comes back. Clues emerge, but nothing has panned out. And then 18-year-old Desirea Ferris goes out, but never makes it home to celebrate her mom's birthday. What happened to these teenagers?
Brian Shaffer is seen on camera going in to a bar with friends, but isn't seen leaving. Friends and family are baffled as to what happened to Brian. And then James Liedtka is seen on camera leaving a bar, but is never heard from again.
A brutal murder sent shock waves through the carnival community, and every performer is a suspect. But with the death of Lobster Boy, truths will be revealed, and a reign of terror will meet a shocking end. Life at the carnival will forever change.
A wealthy small business woman in Florida is shot in the face by a clown delivering flowers and balloons. The shocking crime will go unsolved for 27 years.